2 ms·
The Snowden drop was in 2013. A functioning implementation goes a long way toward herding cats and building positive momentum. Amongst hackers, working code t
by sneak 7y ago
The Snowden drop was in 2013.
A functioning implementation goes a long way toward herding cats and building positive momentum. Amongst hackers, working code trumps a lot of objections; moreso if it is simply opportunistic and doesn't break anything for old clients, and can be disabled by the fearful pedants.
It's also a great starting point for other practical objections: with a working prototype, you can always counter "but what about edge case $x, huh smart guy?!" with a "well, here's a small patch to address $x, it's in the PR now", which is a great way to achieve forward progress.
- nullc 7y agoThe edge cases should all be addressed by the spec. :P I don't recall any objections raised that would be addressed by code. (though also, there have been at various points in time implementations, just not merge ready ones...) In 2013 there were more serious privacy problems in the bitcoin software which probably would have made the encryption less relevant. Most of the known ones were addressed by 2016. I still didn't hear about the bitcoin tie in until Oct 2019, though, sadly.