4 ms·
> "Trust" is always used in "Root of trust" and "Trustworthy computing" to mean "deny software freedom to the user." That's not what "root of trust" means. Roo
by viraptor 7y ago
> "Trust" is always used in "Root of trust" and "Trustworthy computing" to mean "deny software freedom to the user."
That's not what "root of trust" means. Root of trust is normally a certificate which signs other certificates. If you trust that top level certificate to be valid, it means you can trust that the certificates signed by it are valid as well. That's all there is to it.
What someone does with the certificates - whether that's signing TLS traffic, or execution attestation is completely separate. I don't think you'd argue that TLS is used to "deny software freedom to the user" - right? (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Root_certificate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Root_certificate)
"trustworthy computing" is not a technical term, but a marketing phrase. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trustworthy_computing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trustworthy_computing)
You're probably referring to "trusted computing" which is a very specific use of signing and attestation of computing states. It uses the chain of trust in the same way it uses addition (or substitute any higher level concept you want) - you can't say "addition is bad, because it denies software freedom to the user" in this case.
- tremon 7y agoYou're probably referring to "trusted computing" which is a very specific use of signing and attestation of computing states. If it is so specific, why is it present in every single Intel CPU? And why aren't end users able to delete the built-in root of trust and replace it with their own? Trusted computing, as implemented by Intel, is actively hostile to the citizens of a free society. So in this case, I really can say that it denies software freedom to the user.
- viraptor 7y agoYou can disable SGX in your Bios. It don't give you any new features then, it doesn't deny any freedoms either.
- nelgaard 7y ago>I don't think you'd argue that TLS is used to "deny software freedom to the user" - right? No, but if I could not make a website that was not signed by e.g. DigiCert, then I would argue that something was not right.