5 ms·
No. Nationalizing it will politicize pharmaceuticals. (and parties change control every few years of so). Private industry may chase the longevity dollars (ex
by mc32 7y ago
No. Nationalizing it will politicize pharmaceuticals. (and parties change control every few years of so). Private industry may chase the longevity dollars (expensive drugs for rich people who want to make their later years easier), but they also do lots of research in lots of other mundane areas.
The problem is more in the healthcare _system_ whose incentives are not aligned with the patients foremost, but rather is more geared towards extracting as much as possible from insurance companies who in turn are disincentivized to give their patients decent care, in many ways.
- halibutt 7y agoWe should nationalize twitter first. And also make it known that HN is censoring posts related to twitter/dorsey right now. Post attempts resolve with a https://news.ycombinator.com/deadlink https://news.ycombinator.com/deadlink Dorsey is being put on the chopping block by Elliott. Go check Reuters. Yes I know this is unrelated. But HN actively censoring. Holy crap. Sorry for taking over your thread. But seriously. Go try to post the Reuters link
- s1artibartfast 7y agoAgreed. Outcome based pricing is a pretty easy step in the right direction and helps to aligns the stakeholders.The drug company only gets paid if the patients get the desired outcome. The current system is completely bonkers. Insurance company profits are capped at a fixed percent, so they want to drive costs as high as possible. Pharma Benefit managers get paid by insurance based on list prices, so they also want to maximize price. Lastly, the manufacturer gets paid by PBMs based on list price minus kickbacks, and obviously wants to turn a profit
- guerrilla 7y agoAs if medicine hasn't always been political and can somehow avoid that in private hands.
- snarf21 7y agoAgreed. I also think that there are certain endeavors (medicine, space travel, etc.) where we need global cost sharing. Why are drugs cheaper in Canada? A lot of the drugs that go around the world are paid for by the US middle class. This cost sharing also removes the need for patent protections as everyone is opted in and buys from the global source. Obviously there are more details to solve but I'd like to see this approach tried.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoNationalizing it will politicize pharmaceuticals You need to keep the politicians out of the pipeline and put physicians and pharmacologists in charge. It's more difficult in a country where the public service has been gutted for 40 years, but it has to be done. Right now there is insufficient research in antibiotics and tropical diseases and far too much in cancer. The market isn't going to fix that misallocation of funds.
- bitwize 7y ago> Nationalizing it will politicize pharmaceuticals. (and parties change control every few years of so). That's easy to fix. Pass a law forbidding any non-progressive political parties from forming or having a say in government. What could possibly go wrong?
- HarryHirsch 7y agoConsidering how many politicians try to score votes through speaking against the HPV vaccine and how many lives are lost though entirely preventable cervical cancer, this kind of remark is completely unneeded. Statistics are here: https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/cervical/statistics/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/cervical/statistics/index.htm
- taborj 7y ago> What could possibly go wrong? Let's look to some one-party countries to find out! Oh, look, everything.
- mc32 7y ago> “Pass a law forbidding any non-progressive political parties from forming...” What? That runs against the bill of rights right out of the gate.
- thulecitizen 7y agoYour argument is such horseshit. Privatization has been a disaser already, and wreaked havoc on the American people. Today, most pharmaceuticals are developed by the government. Private corporations take existing research and medicines, tweak them enough to be considered 'different', give them new names and then market them heavily to uncritical citizens. Corporations act as parasites. [1][2] > Nationalizing it will politicize pharmaceuticals Please could you read the etymology of 'political'? Everything is an ongoing dialogue. To me it's implicit that everything is political, because society is constantly evolving. What is not an ongoing debate or dialogue? Science is a constant renegotiation. New hypotheses and theories are formulated all the time, as well as a constantly shifting diversity of approach and apparatus. Things constantly evolve, new technologies emerge, new medicines come out etc.. Open dialogue is a core pillar of a healthy democracy, where we continuously re-explore and re-frame our understanding of the world around us. How I see it, something doesn't 'become' political in the way you suggest, at all. It has always been political already. With your 'politicize' argument you erase any earlier historic debate and turn it into a black and white frame, lacking any nuance. This means politics is reduced to two modes: 1. something is non-political - because I agree with the policy, vs. 2. something is political - because I disagree with it. I see the term 'political' used as a pejorative like this by ignorant people who first deny the nature of the ongoing debate of democratic governance. When they see someone proposing a strategy they don't agree with, they use the word 'political' as a scare tactic. Please do not fall in this trap and share unsupported claims simply because you might not understand the dynamics enough to have an informed decision. Please do not scaremonger, because you are just shutting down healthy debate. Please could you explore others' perspectives and give more context of your own (for example by sharing your background/skills) so we can understand your angle? Or at the least could you come with sources to back up your arguments, so that we can understand what you see, and how? [1] https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-1027-mazzucato-big-pharma-prices-20151027-story.html https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-1027-mazzucato-b... [2] https://web.archive.org/web/20160430010410/https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/02/11/big-pharmaceutical-companies-are-spending-far-more-on-marketing-than-research/ https://web.archive.org/web/20160430010410/https://www.washi...
- _Wintermute 7y ago
- nyxtom 7y agoYou would think that's a big part of the problem, but some of these issues like: - Pharmaceutical companies sponsoring/paying doctors to push their products - Paying doctors to put their names on papers they haven't even written or reward for research they never actually did - Companies that engage in patent thicketing and product hopping (drug companies abusing the patent system to hold onto market share and prevent any generic competition) - Pharmaceutical companies engaging in price gouging tactics
- dariusj18 7y agoAnd preventing these things are the role of government, not practicing them itself.
- mc32 7y agoThat happens in countries with universal or semi socialized medicine too. Obviously these are two different things. What I’m saying is whether or not healthcare is private or nationalized, the pharma industry in those countries are not nationalized (like say the way they were in the eastern bloc).