4 ms·
> Intel CSME firmware also implements the TPM software module, which allows storing encryption keys without needing an additional TPM chip—and many computers do
by amluto 7y ago
> Intel CSME firmware also implements the TPM software module, which allows storing encryption keys without needing an additional TPM chip—and many computers do not have such chips.
And that was the real error. The TPM should be a TPM. It could be on die, but it should be an entirely isolated device with its own RAM, no DMA, no modules, and no other funny business.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lima 7y agoInternal TPM is more secure for attestation. You can MitM the LPC bus with an external TPM, faking PCRs.
- lxgr 7y agoThat sure is an interesting decision, given that other big players (Apple with the Secure Enclave, Google with Titan) have been moving into the opposite direction.
- indolering 7y agoYeah, but that would cost money! Intel hasn't suffered major economic repercussions for any of their other security issues ... so why bother? At ~400 million chips/year, a $0.10 increase in component cost would translate to $40 million in lost profits.