8 ms·
This is great news! Undermining remote attestation is a win for the open web and free society. And perhaps it means we can get Libreboot on something newer than
by mindslight 7y ago
This is great news! Undermining remote attestation is a win for the open web and free society. And perhaps it means we can get Libreboot on something newer than Ivy Bridge.
- Karunamon 7y agoThis was my first thought as well. It seems these management engine tools have only two uses in the real world: enterprise IT, and various forms of DRM. Both exist to treat the user as a hostile entity.
- mindslight 7y agoWell it would be nice for cloud servers, so that you wouldn't have to trust the hosting provider. But given the choice of needing to trust (cloud: intel, home: intel), and (cloud: intel+provider, home: nobody), it would be foolish to not choose the latter! At the individual level, remote attestation has a particularly terrible end game. Think of all those websites that attempt to enforce their desired business whims client-side, that we rightfully laugh at - browser fingerprinting, image save as, anti-adblock, etc. Now imagine they're successful!
- anonymousDan 7y agoCloud computing (SGX).
- baybal2 7y agoGiven the presence of 4k web-dls (original, not reencoded content,) somebody must have the key, or they must have managed to pwn the DRM on an even deeper level, like tapping the memory (which is even worse.) Another possibility is still a source leak, where 4k content gets lifted off Netflixes own internal content storage.
- jandrese 7y agoOr a simple HDMI defeat and re-encode. It only takes one guy to put it out on the net. DRM is an inherently flawed concept.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sounds 7y agoThe content is watermarked by the time it is available on HDMI. The guy who re-encoded it would get a knock on the door.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoXOR frames captured via two different accounts.
- wizzwizz4 7y agoWouldn't you need three? Or, better still, do a bitwise 3 of 5 / integer median on the pixel values.
- herogreen 7y agoExcept if the watermark is terribly designed, that will not work. There is a lot of information that you can hide from the eye in a video.
- effie 7y agoWhat would that accomplish? If you want to exclude differences, use AND.
- mschuster91 7y agoNo. HDMI/HDCP does not do watermarking or any other modification to content. Cinema DCP packages, however, do - it's either watermarked at the DCP distributor or in the decryption module, but that stuff is out of reach for most warez crews.
- aftbit 7y agoJust curious, how can one distinguish original content from a full-res re-encode without access to the actual bits of the original file?
- bavell 7y agoThis may not be exactly what you're asking for but every re-encode introduces additional noise (generational error). Over many re-encodings (even at same high bitrate/quality) the noise will accumulate in a predictable manner. See [0] for an interesting deep-dive blog post on the subject. Now, as for whether or not you can distinguish the re-encoding from it's original source.... difficult but plausible in certain scenarios? Perhaps if the content was heavily re-encoded to the point where you can statistically determine the presence of the generational noise. With only a single re-encode it may be impossible to determine. [0] https://goughlui.com/2016/11/22/video-compression-x264-crf-generational-loss-testing/ https://goughlui.com/2016/11/22/video-compression-x264-crf-g...
- effie 7y agoHash the file you have, then compare to the hash of the official version.
- holtalanm 7y agowhat about drive encryption? I'm a little un-versed in hardware related to security, but my understanding of the article was that, given the ability to essentially MitM the TPM, anyone could unencrypt the contents of an encrypted drive, potentially even remotely. if so, that is definitely not a good thing.
- Karunamon 7y agoThe problem with drive encryption at the mainboard level is that it comes with a free side order of vendor lock-in. Apple is a good example here. You can't even touch the internal storage whether you want it encrypted or not, because all access to the onboard storage is gated by their black box security processor. I'd rather just forego the silicon and do it all in software, since there's no way to ensure that the OEMs aren't being bastards. Another reason is that the hardware vendor is in a great, centralized position to be backdoored either by hackers or the bad guys with badges.
- Avamander 7y agoRemote attestation is often the only way to do secure computing on platforms with unknown security. For example things like i-voting would immensely benefit from a secure, anti-tamper computing environment. DRM is another thing however, yes.
- mindslight 7y agoIndividuals being able to choose their operating system when accessing bank websites, and being able to keep secrets to themselves, has much more bearing on every day life than "internet voting". Also note that voting etc could easily be implemented with smart cards (eg SIMs, credit card chips, etc). These are still trusted computing, but are at least limited in scope. Top-down control has no place in general CPUs if we wish to remain an open society.
- M2Ys4U 7y agoVoting using computers is such a terrible idea even in principal that a trust breach like this is irrelevant.
- justincredible 7y agoCan you explain why it's a terrible idea in principle? That is, assuming uncrackable software with foolproof authentication, why is it a terrible idea?
- Avamander 7y agoI find the potential lack of voter supression would be worth exploring the field. I mean, I can see US's terrible governmental IT systems and where the scepticism comes from, but I think it/IT could be done well.
- jnwatson 7y agoI, too, prefer not to know when my box has been blue pilled. Remote attestation is required for many privacy-preserving activities. It isn't just DRM.
- mindslight 7y agoI prefer my box to not be blue-pilled, rather than merely knowing if it has been double blue-pilled. I didn't say it was just DRM. Remote attestation creates a vulnerability whereby remote entities demand that you attest to running a software environment that they control. It's possible to do boot verification and attestation without baking in privileged manufacturer keys. If the attestation key were generated and installed by the owner, they could prove everything to themselves remotely, without being forced to prove anything to hostile parties. If this were the case here, I wouldn't be cheering.
- pb82 7y agoDo you mean Coreboot? Because as far as i know Libreboot still only supports Core2 era hardware. Ivy Bridge would be a huge upgrade in comparison.
- mindslight 7y agoOops, yes. What I actually meant is blob-cleaned coreboot (ie Thinkpad X230). FWIW Libreboot proper does run on IvyBridge-era Opteron 6300.
- floatboth 7y agoThe blobs you have to include in Coreboot for modern CPUs don't have much to do with technical restrictions. A pwnage of the ME does not do the reverse-engineering-and-rewriting effort on the FSP for you.