4 ms·
> Even if we don't agree, cryptocurrencies are now an unstoppable force. I'm sorry, but this is far from obvious. > We can say that the worst case scenario fo
by Nursie 7y ago
> Even if we don't agree, cryptocurrencies are now an unstoppable force.
I'm sorry, but this is far from obvious.
> We can say that the worst case scenario for cryptocurrencies would be to share the same destiny as the BitTorrent protocol [3] where there is a lot of usage but is not popular.
Actually, the worst case is a crash and the whole scene collapsing in a mess of criminal trials and bitter recriminations.
Just because cryptocurrencies are 'legalised' doesn't mean a whole lot for the long term. In fact I would hope to see this sort of thing result in much more active enforcement of existing legal and financial protections, something the cryptocurrency scene has been unnervingly able to dodge so far.
> gaining territory
Not in many places. They seem to be seen by most folks I encounter as both passe (that was so 2017!) and basically as crimebux.
I'm also enjoying the frantic handwaving away of power usage concerns in the wake of the current rebirth of the green movement, post Thunberg.
- wslh 7y ago> Actually, the worst case is a crash and the whole scene collapsing in a mess of criminal trials and bitter recriminations. As I said in my comment and my post[4]: [even if they crash] stable coins are one of the major drivers of cryptocurrencies/blockchains and by definition fully collateralized stable coins does not crash or if they crash it is because the underlying standard financial system crashes. I also highlight that in this context the most interesting thing about blockchains is that "Openness and interoperability have become more important than decentralization". [4] The Rise of Stable Coins: Beyond Facebook Libra: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-stable-coins-beyond-facebook-libra-sebastian-raul-wain/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-stable-coins-beyond-face...
- Nursie 7y ago> fully collateralized stable coins Which ones are those? The biggest (Tether) have admitted that they are not fully collateralised and withrawn their claims to such. In a court filing last year they announced they had around 73% of the funds available in 'cash or cash-like instruments', but even that hasn't really been verified, nor is it apparent whether "cash-like instruments" includes other cryptocurrencies.
- wslh 7y agoUSDC for example.
- Nursie 7y agoOh, and >I also highlight that in this context the most interesting thing about blockchains is that "Openness and interoperability have become more important than decentralization". The most interesting thing to me about "blockchains" is how the hype train is still limping on, after almost zero actual delivery of anything useful or world-changing. I expect it to continue to lose steam, as all the pupported use-cases turn out (as they all have so far) either to be some sort of impractical techno-utopian dream, an unnecessary complication where a database works just fine (better in fact), or an outright scam.
- wslh 7y agoI am sharing your sentiment but not 100%. My point there was different, and I highlighted that was an irony: now we have a way to interoperate with less friction than banks or other financial institutions thanks to a new infrastructure. This infrastructure could not be a blockchain and can be a better technology based more in typical federations and less on BFT like descentralization.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoWhy exactly shall I hold my USD funds in USDC instead of just, you know, US Dollars? That just doesn't make any damn sense, whatsoever.
- herendin2 7y agoFor example, USD 10,000 is the absolute maximum you can bring into or take out of the US, or move between accounts in the US, without intrusive and possibly annoying declarations of source of funds, and potential exposure to instant civil forfeiture if you are deemed suspicious [0]. Stablecoins may not be practically subject to these restrictions (they may have other very serious risks and limitations, but not the same ones as USD). So choose whatever currency is best for you. Isn't it nice to have a choice? [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22489103 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22489103
- dmos62 7y agoEven if most exchanges are shut down and the price crashes, the network can't be undone, in that, if there's demand, it's sufficiently resilient to continue to exist. For crypto to function as currency we need it to be at least somewhat stable. We currently have that. We also need to be able to exchange it, which we also have. Remember that decentralized, anonymous and trustless crypto<->fiat exchanges are possible, like Bisq https://bisq.network/ https://bisq.network/
- Nursie 7y ago> if there's demand And if there isn't? One of the failure states for cryptocurrencies at present seems to be a period of falling demand accompanied with a falling hashrate, at which point the blockchain can be manipulated relatviely cheaply by bad actors and all hell breaks loose. Bisq appears to rely on bank transfer services, which are usually traceable, reversible etc, so I'm not sure it's quite the panacea one would hope.
- dmos62 7y ago> > if there's demand > And if there isn't? I feel like this question is meant for speculators and investors. > Bisq appears to rely on bank transfer services, which are usually traceable, reversible Bank trasnfers are of course not anonymous, but there's nothing linking them to crypto trading, because those are direct transfers from buyer to seller. The platform, Bisq, doesn't ever touch the money. Bank transfers are sometimes reversible (called chargeback), but for example for SEPA that's only in the case of theft and you're not actually obligated to return the money, but you would have to explain why you received it. The worst that I've heard happen is a bank account being frozen, because of suspect activity (unexplained transfers from many different private individuals). Bisq has effective mechanisms for dealing with the chargeback risk. If anyone reading this is at all interested in trustless system, I highly recommend taking a closer look at Bisq.
- Nursie 7y agoDoesn't sound massively trustless to me, and it does sound like passing the risk of frozen accounts etc onto the user.
- rolltiide 7y ago> I'm also enjoying the frantic handwaving away of power usage concerns Because headlines focus on the amount of power used and not the source of power used, which is overwhelmingly renewable and wasted energy that had no prior economic use which undermines the whole reductive argument about power used, and is an outcome resolved purely by market forces. Let me know if you would like examples for your independent corroboration.
- Nursie 7y ago> which is overwhelmingly renewable and wasted energy that had no prior economic use And here's the handwaving. Here's a counter-example: https://www.coindesk.com/a-new-york-power-plant-is-mining-50k-worth-of-bitcoin-a-day https://www.coindesk.com/a-new-york-power-plant-is-mining-50...