4 ms·
In this phase of blockchain/cryptocurrency a link is created between the two worlds that is neither cryptoanarchist nor anticrypto. We are seeing different stra
by wslh 7y ago
In this phase of blockchain/cryptocurrency a link is created between the two worlds that is neither cryptoanarchist nor anticrypto. We are seeing different strategies on how states are dealing with this. For example, Germany initiatives [1] are different than US state based ones [2].
Even if we don't agree, cryptocurrencies are now an unstoppable force. We can say that the worst case scenario for cryptocurrencies would be to share the same destiny as the BitTorrent protocol [3] where there is a lot of usage but is not popular. Cryptocurrencies are moving beyond BitTorrent fate because there are many financial institutions, regulators, etc that are connecting these two worlds.
Ironically, it is more practical to use stable coins for global transfers than the volatile currencies in the permissionless blockchains that host these stable coins [4], and also more practical and cheaper than a wire transfer between two US accounts.
I am not saying that cryptocurrencies are not used for illicit purposes also, or that there is some magic intrinsic value behind them. Just saying the in the political context cryptocurrencies are gaining territory.
[1] Germany on chain: National Blockchain Strategy Released - https://medium.com/@philippsandner/germany-national-blockchain-strategy-released-1420e9d066f7 https://medium.com/@philippsandner/germany-national-blockcha... & Bitcoin officially recognized as a legal financial instrument in Germany: https://www.somagnews.com/bitcoin-officially-recognized-legal-financial-instrument-germany/ https://www.somagnews.com/bitcoin-officially-recognized-lega...
[2] State Regulations on Virtual Currency and Blockchain Technologies: https://www.carltonfields.com/insights/publications/2018/state-regulations-on-virtual-currency-and-blockchain-technologies https://www.carltonfields.com/insights/publications/2018/sta...
[3] File-Sharing and VPN Traffic Grow Explosively: https://torrentfreak.com/filesharing-and-vpn-traffic-grow-explosively-191009/ https://torrentfreak.com/filesharing-and-vpn-traffic-grow-ex...
[4] The Rise of Stable Coins: Beyond Facebook Libra: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-stable-coins-beyond-facebook-libra-sebastian-raul-wain/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-stable-coins-beyond-face...
- Nursie 7y ago> Even if we don't agree, cryptocurrencies are now an unstoppable force. I'm sorry, but this is far from obvious. > We can say that the worst case scenario for cryptocurrencies would be to share the same destiny as the BitTorrent protocol [3] where there is a lot of usage but is not popular. Actually, the worst case is a crash and the whole scene collapsing in a mess of criminal trials and bitter recriminations. Just because cryptocurrencies are 'legalised' doesn't mean a whole lot for the long term. In fact I would hope to see this sort of thing result in much more active enforcement of existing legal and financial protections, something the cryptocurrency scene has been unnervingly able to dodge so far. > gaining territory Not in many places. They seem to be seen by most folks I encounter as both passe (that was so 2017!) and basically as crimebux. I'm also enjoying the frantic handwaving away of power usage concerns in the wake of the current rebirth of the green movement, post Thunberg.
- wslh 7y ago> Actually, the worst case is a crash and the whole scene collapsing in a mess of criminal trials and bitter recriminations. As I said in my comment and my post[4]: [even if they crash] stable coins are one of the major drivers of cryptocurrencies/blockchains and by definition fully collateralized stable coins does not crash or if they crash it is because the underlying standard financial system crashes. I also highlight that in this context the most interesting thing about blockchains is that "Openness and interoperability have become more important than decentralization". [4] The Rise of Stable Coins: Beyond Facebook Libra: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-stable-coins-beyond-facebook-libra-sebastian-raul-wain/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-stable-coins-beyond-face...
- Nursie 7y ago> fully collateralized stable coins Which ones are those? The biggest (Tether) have admitted that they are not fully collateralised and withrawn their claims to such. In a court filing last year they announced they had around 73% of the funds available in 'cash or cash-like instruments', but even that hasn't really been verified, nor is it apparent whether "cash-like instruments" includes other cryptocurrencies.
- wslh 7y agoUSDC for example.
- Nursie 7y agoOh, and >I also highlight that in this context the most interesting thing about blockchains is that "Openness and interoperability have become more important than decentralization". The most interesting thing to me about "blockchains" is how the hype train is still limping on, after almost zero actual delivery of anything useful or world-changing. I expect it to continue to lose steam, as all the pupported use-cases turn out (as they all have so far) either to be some sort of impractical techno-utopian dream, an unnecessary complication where a database works just fine (better in fact), or an outright scam.
- Hinrik 7y ago>The HN camp is mainly anti cryptocurrency What's the point of starting your comment by unnecessarily painting this entire community with such a broad brush and dismissing the nuanced opinions on cryptocurrencies found here? What does it add? It just makes me more skeptical of whatever you're about to say, to the point where I barely feel like it's worth reading.
- wslh 7y agoI just edited my comment and removed that part. As an active HN community member I shared my feelings here but never said that all the HN community was anti crypto. I said "mainly" because I see a shift to the anti crypto camp. I can obviously be wrong but it is based on my cognitive device reading thousands of messages for years.
- calibas 7y agoI think I speak for more than just myself when I say that blockchain has enormous potential and cryptocurrencies have already proven themselves to be a viable technology. The problem is more the social and economic aspects of cryptocurrencies. The community is filled with scammers, get rich quick schemes, and self-appointed blockchain experts who have no idea what a Merkle tree is. All these people who see cryptocurrencies as this profitable investment creates a roller coaster market that undermines their usefulness as an actual currency. What you want in a currency is stability, you don't want to suddenly not be able to afford rent because the market collapsed over the last week.
- codehalo 7y agoThere is an abundance of evidence that HN was one of the most anti cryptocurrency sites. It was/is surprisingly bizarre, given the expectation that the posters would be more knowledgeable of future tech than other sites. History has now shown that it way too high of an expectation.
- blaser-waffle 7y ago> It was/is surprisingly bizarre, given the expectation that the posters would be more knowledgeable of future tech than other sites. Is it? A few people got super rich, a few others did alright, and there have been several notable failures or downright frauds. The huge amount of obvious marketing pitches also did (and does) make it sound super sketchy. But I agree it's here to stay.
- qroshan 7y agoIt'll take less than 0.0001% of any State Actor's military budget to perform a 51% attack on public blockchain and I'm not even talking about simply taking over the Miners with a stroke of Pen or a Phone Call Delusional to call it Unstoppable
- blueprint 7y agoStablecoins so far are not able to be cryptocurrencies. They involve the oracle problem. No functional cryptocurrency operates w outside data like that.
- wslh 7y agoAs I said in [4]: "Furthermore, stable coins are centralized, but they take advantage of the interoperability features and open finance capabilities in decentralized blockchains. Openness and interoperability have become more important than decentralization." [4] The Rise of Stable Coins: Beyond Facebook Libra: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-stable-coins-beyond-facebook-libra-sebastian-raul-wain/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/rise-stable-coins-beyond-face...