3 ms·
I'm still convinced that prime majority of ML, and "self driving" is plain fraud to get money out of investors, big businesses, and fat employers. The best pro
by baybal2 7y ago
I'm still convinced that prime majority of ML, and "self driving" is plain fraud to get money out of investors, big businesses, and fat employers.
The best proof is that even with billions spent, the best contenders got marginal improvement over what Mercedes had in 1990 with discreet algorithms and no neural/fuzzy logic
Doesn't drive in anything, but the best conditions, and needs human intervention every 5km unless a passenger is ready to wait few minutes every time it has to pass a complex intersection the safe way.
I think them finally employing a mm-wave radar this time is an evidence to them backing off to more "dumb" and sure to work solution as a last line of defence once their fancy imaging/neural algo fails.
The question is: if after all they weren't able to make their neural net algorithm to best the "dumb" approach, why use that fancy "artificial vision" to start with?
- shuwusxuu2he 7y agoFull self driving is probably wishful thinking for the next decade at minimum. That said, even just getting to a point where you could use a human+tool combo to reliably shepard a second truck to a depot at the outskirts of a city would have profound logistics implications.
- trymas 7y ago> what Mercedes had in 1990 with discreet algorithms and no neural/fuzzy logic Do you have any more information about it? I could find only abstract info that the system existed: https://www.autoevolution.com/news/a-short-history-of-mercedes-benz-autonomous-driving-technology-68148.html https://www.autoevolution.com/news/a-short-history-of-merced...
- mikejb 7y ago> The best proof is that even with billions spent, the best contenders got marginal improvement over what Mercedes had in 1990 with discreet algorithms and no neural/fuzzy logic Can you elaborate on that? I haven't found much on that, e.g. w.r.t. the Mercedes system handling other vehicles, pedestrians, street signs, unexpected situations (roadworks, children playing, etc.) - from what I was able to gather, the two systems aren't even remotely comparable. Edit: Mercedes was able to go on a highway, follow the lane, and keep distance to the car in front. Claiming "the best contenders got marginal improvement" is heavily biased at best - it feels like an attempt to justify an outdated opinion, rather than having facts inform it.
- azernik 7y agoThey haven't been relying solely on "fancy imaging/neural algo" - every self-driving car since the DARPA challenge has used LIDAR, and a good chunk of the self-driving R&D funding has gone into making those cheaper. The LIDAR they're bragging about in this blog post is them adding four more sensors to the car for short range, on top of the one they already had on top. mm-wave radar gives them better sensing for long ranges and in bad weather, but isn't a fundamental change in approach from their already-sensor-heavy tech.
- 2rsf 7y ago> them finally employing a mm-wave radar this time is an evidence to them backing off to more "dumb" and sure to work solution as a last line of defence once their fancy imaging/neural algo fails AFAIK from little experience in the industry interpreting Radar images is not easy nor dumb For example read here: http://homepage.tudelft.nl/e15f9/pdf/Uysal_MAXWELL_19.pdf http://homepage.tudelft.nl/e15f9/pdf/Uysal_MAXWELL_19.pdf
- dannyw 7y agoAccording to their latest Californian DMV filing, Waymo's disengagement rate was 0.076 per 1,000 miles. This means for every disengagement, they've driven for 13,158 miles on average. That's ~1000~ EDIT: 4, thank you; orders of magnitudes from your "5km". Could a Mercedes in the 1990s drive itself for 13k miles without human intervention?
- baybal2 7y agoThis is a debated number, with people telling that they don't count anything, but actual "stall" when the system stands still and can't do anything, as disengagement. And accounts of stalled Waymos in the middle of the road are too frequent to believe them
- jeen02 7y ago> And accounts of stalled Waymos in the middle of the road are too frequent to believe them You gonna provide a source for that?
- azernik 7y agoDisengagement is whenever the human test driver has to intervene. The car stalling in the middle of the road would only be counted as a disengagement if it doesn't recover on its own.
- graphpapa 7y ago13000m ~> 20000km Order of 200000: 10^4 Order of 5: 1^0 Conclusion: difference in order of magnitudes = 4 (not 1000)
- ohazi 7y ago> This means for every disengagement, they've driven for 13,158 miles on average. That's 1000 orders of magnitudes from your "5km". That's four orders of magnitude, not a thousand.
- dannyw 7y agoThank you for the correction :)