How much of these subsidies are cash, and how much are tax breaks? Cash subsidies from taxpayers are bad, I agree, but at least with the tax breaks, the taxpaye

How much of these subsidies are cash, and how much are tax breaks? Cash subsidies from taxpayers are bad, I agree, but at least with the tax breaks, the taxpayers are not worse off: if the alternative is no factory at all, then they don't lose anything on the tax breaks, because that tax revenue wouldn't have had existed anyway.