4 ms·
It seems like Paul Graham is being asked a bunch of questions not at all related to his field of expertise. I point out once again that the only reason he’s on
by dangus 7y ago
It seems like Paul Graham is being asked a bunch of questions not at all related to his field of expertise.
I point out once again that the only reason he’s on the front page here is his association with YC. He often has nothing revelatory to say and yet he’s on here due to the cult of personality.
Every time I mention this it stirs up controversy which in itself kind of proves my point. People want to hear what this dude says because they fantasize about the pure-luck impossibility selling a company to Yahoo! years ago and getting to spend the rest of your life as a semi-retired wealthy man with ample time to write essays.
- skrebbel 7y agoThis is like complaining when an interviewer asks Brad Pitt for life hacks. I.e. it's like complaining about every celebrity biopic ever. Your point is valid, just like my argument that the sky is blue.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoExcept tech folks are supposed to be more evidence-driven, and not prone to praising pointless fluff as wisdom. Worth mentioning at least, to warn the careless to not get sucked in?
- hackinthebochs 7y agoThe fact that PG was a founder, then went on to build a company/investment vehicle that is relevant to founders is "evidence" of relevant celebrity in this space.
- dangus 7y agoDo you think this is the sort of forum that should turn to posting celebrity biopics? If you like, I could post some stories about the kind of clothes Mark Zuckerberg is wearing today. Personally, I’d prefer to see interesting technical or related content and I’m disappointed that other people interested in technology upvoted an article about what a wealthy person thinks of Elizabeth Warren.
- lawrenceyan 7y agoHarsh words, but there is truth ingrained in them. I appreciate your willingness to address what otherwise might be seen as too abrasive or thorny to approach normally.
- alexpetralia 7y agoEric Weinstein calls this phenomenon "earns as an X, spends as a Y". Someone earns credibility in one domain and is suddenly qualified to spend it in any other domain.
- ALittleLight 7y agoThere are many rich people in the world and I don't read their essays or blog posts or whatever. I came to know PG from his essays and think they're pretty interesting. I also like the fantasy of selling a company and retiring early to write essays and work on my software projects.
- benjaminsuch 7y agoWhy do you focus about who is interviewed rather than what the questions and the answers are? If the answers are still interesting, it doesn't matter what the person has done before or is doing now. Instead of bragging about the person who is interviewed, point out answers you don't like or agree with and post your point of view.
- braythwayt 7y agoHere’s a thought experiment: Repost the exact same interview, but substitute your name and experience for his. Give the same opinions and life advice. If it makes it to the front page of HN, then we have some evidence that this community cares more about what is said than with who says it. On the other hand, if this community ignores it, than we have some evidence that this community values who gives the advice as much as the advice itself. Now, if the latter is the case, if ”who gives the advice” matters for some reason, then it seems relevant to discuss who gives the advice, and whether their life experience lends weight to their advice.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoOddly enough this is part of what made 4chan enticing in the earlier years I went on it. Everyone is forced into anonymity to strip them of this sort of bias. Since nobody knows anybody's identity for certain, whatever you post must speak for itself to hold any merit. Also, 4chan is more than just their 'random' board.
- AlchemistCamp 7y agoThe next question is, how did pg become pg? His essays are how I learned of both HN and YC and from founders I've spoken with the very same essays played a critical role in getting YC off the ground in the early days. Of course he was already a (relatively minor) entrepreneurial success through Viaweb, which gave the essays a boost. But when starting Viaweb, he was just a smart 30-ish guy who had published a couple of books on a niche programming language. It's easy to see how this would feel like a lucky chain of events and that a random person could have jumped in at any given point and done as well, but I'm very skeptical of that hypothesis.
- statictype 7y agoI like to hear what he has to say about anything because he’s a thoughtful essayist and has generally interesting things to say. Its not cult worship. I feel that way about other people as well (who aren't wealthy well known venture capitalists)
- dangus 7y agoReplace him with Oprah or Joel Osteen in your first sentence and see if you feel any different about following someone in this manner.
- statictype 7y ago“I like to hear what Oprah says about anything because shes a thoughtful essayist and has generally interesting things to say” ? Ok.. should I feel differently about that?
- earthtourist 7y agoI find Paul Graham to stand out even among the smartest people whose work I follow. He's prone to regular and incredible insights. Like a great stand up comedian, he frequently notices things most of us manage to miss. He has his blind spots and faults, of course, like every human ever. And there is truth to the charge that his current popularity is inflated due to him being an investor. Many investors receive an undeserved amount of attention and adulation. After all, their entire job is to hand out millions of dollars. That tends to incline people towards paying attention. But I, along with many thousands of others, have been reading Paul Graham's essays since long before YC. That's how he launched YC (and Reddit, and Hacker News). This is proof that he was genuinely compelling long before he was an investor. His Lisp books were also great. So he was a successful book author, successful founder, successful essayist, then a successful investor. Not an example of someone failing upwards, as is disappointingly-common in The Valley.
- nwienert 7y agoI’ve read most of his stuff and find him to be no more compelling than just about anyone. He just packages it all up and puts it out there. But his foot-in-mouth ratio is also really high and he often tweets or writes about the most banal things as though he were discovering new physics.
- gist 7y agoI actually don't fault him (despite my other comments) for writing about 'the most banal things' I put that on the person who is reading that thinks it's more than it is. And seem to celebrate it. Likewise I remember when someone wrote (don't remember who) how they thought it was great that the janitor put a supply of plastic trash can liners at the bottom of the trash can so they'd be there in supply when needed (and when the trash was emptied by taking the existing filled bag). This is something I had done myself forever. Just seemed obvious. So it's more "what's the big deal why are you making like the janitor has figured out some really ingenious trick'"? Also the other thing that I would guess bothers people is when they say the same things it would get no notice at all (from friends or in an online comment). So it's more like 'why is this guy getting attention and I am not for these simple thoughts'? (This might have been parodied on SNL as 'deep thoughts by Jack Handy' iirc.
- vixen99 7y agoIf as you say 'he has often nothing to say ...' etc., why would you bother to read the interview. It's not obligatory nor to keep mentioning your view.
- AlchemistCamp 7y agoThat's is the most underrated comment on this entire, horribly derailed thread.
- the_watcher 7y ago> pure-luck impossibility selling a company to Yahoo! Regardless of how you feel about pg, his selling Viaweb to Yahoo was not pure luck - he had to build Viaweb first.
- dangus 7y agoThe luck part is the timing. As a product there’s nothing about Viaweb that was particularly exotic even for the time. For comparison, Amazon was founded the year before. eBay was also founded in 1995. Enabling businesses to sell stuff online as an alternative to phone or fax orders was probably the most obvious commercial application of the World Wide Web.
- the_watcher 7y agoAFAIK it was the first web application, which by definition makes it unique (since there can only be one "first"). The innovation was that they were selling a store-builder that didn't require the business to have their own servers, not ecommerce.
- shams93 7y agoNot quite pure luck he was in the right place at the right time with the right skills. I would say this is nearly impossible to reproduce today compared to the 90s its not exactly a wide open field, niches are filled rapidly and there is arguably a massive glut of smart people trying to escape desperate poverty. This is why I see Bernie signs on every corner.
- jiveturkey 7y agoThe point is fair, except that PG is not your average dummy. Revelation is usually (tbh) in hindsight anyway, and PG has seen a lot. That said, I don't enjoy his essays one bit. They are not thought provoking, they don't offer any real lessons, they are his thought of the moment. Like how he had kids now he likes to talk about having kids. We don't need more blogging (esp. not in tech blog) about the things you can only know if you actually have kids anyway. Reading it is a waste of time. Writing about it is actually fantastic for the author, so I don't fault him. Writing is great. But the cult of personality that actually draws readers rubs me the wrong way. His are poor writings, for audiences I mean. I'd rather watch TK than PG.
- gist 7y agoI think growing up 'back in the day' some of us may have known people that we viewed as smart and having just good answers about things in general (if not a topic they had specific expertise in). Someone in the neighborhood older or a friend. But the thing is that was more or less earned. They'd say something and then over time you'd find they were right or not and so you tended to listen to what they said more and consider them 'smart'. Sometimes you'd consider them smart just because they had answers to things that you didn't [1] and often even because you didn't (pre-internet) have a way to see if they were even right at all. So it was easier for sure to run circles around people when knowledge wasn't so accessible. But very generally wasn't something (that I recall from my experience) bestowed on people based on things that vaulted them to prominence which could be attributed to luck. [1] A good example of this on HN for me is tptacek who amazes me with his writing and what he knows (that I don't) but honestly I don't know enough to know how correct he is and I suspect others may not as well. Noting that on a topic (that I will not mention) that I am an expert on a HN discussion is typically totally wrong many times.
- tim333 7y agoThere's a difference between a 'cult of personality' which dictionary.com has as "promoting adulation of a living national leader or public figure, as one encouraged by Stalin" and following someone because you find them interesting.