3 ms·
To some extent, the pie fallacy exists. But if your major life work is Viaweb (which was really worthless and sold during the bubble to Yahoo contacts), perhaps
by liqla 7y ago
To some extent, the pie fallacy exists. But if your major
life work is Viaweb (which was really worthless and sold
during the bubble to Yahoo contacts), perhaps you should
not talk about pies.
There are a huge number of Open Source contributors here
who have produced way more wealth than Graham.
- nickpp 7y agoPaul Graham's major life work (so far) looks to be YC, not Viaweb.
- akp10 7y agoThe pivotal work (with rtm and trevorj!) was Viaweb. Without that he would not have been able to start YC. Also I presume he had substantial help in starting YC. Many successful people like Bechtolsheim and Khosla go into the VC business. Still these two would probably list Sun as their major work. The OSS contributor comment still applies: In the technology business one would need to go into the league of companies like Intel to even start comparing the wealth generated by companies vs. the wealth generated by OSS.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jannotti 7y agoI mean, he had to learn to read too. If not for that, he'd never have founded viaweb! True, but not very interesting. I happen to think both were fairly innovative. Both viaweb and YC were at the forefront of a newish idea that seems pretty obvious in retrospect: Server based applications, and startup incubators. Both existed before to some extent, but pg recognized their value pretty quickly, and did them both well enough to make an impact. (I'd learn toward more credit incubators and less for server-based apps, but whatever.)
- alqwlsq 7y agoI think you are rewriting history. Viaweb was selling shovels (enable small businesses to generate websites) Ycombinator is selling shovels (enable people to launch startups, initially for an outrageously low investment). Selling shovels was one of the fundamental concepts during the first bubble, nothing new. Webshops were nothing new either. His innovation was turning startups into movement, largely using this website and blog about it so tirelessly (always using the term "startup") that he is credited with the concept.
- jannotti 7y agoViaweb was founded in 1995 and sold in 1998. It WAS part of the first bubble. And no, people were not routinely writing web server based "applications" in 1995. They were, at best, making some early websites. Also nobody was thinking of pages as screens in an app powered by server based software. OpenMarket, I suppose. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Market But they were only founded in 1994.
- mdonahoe 7y agoYC (and other VC) doesn’t seem like selling shovels to me. If you’re selling shovels, you can succeed without any of your customers ever finding gold again. You happily sell shovels even if you knew the customers could never find gold. When you’re buying percentages of multiple companies, you need somebody to succeed for you to succeed.
- onetimemanytime 7y agoPaul is seen as God here and that's overreacting, but his major life work is the company on who's website you're on. He has mentored a lot of startups. https://www.ycombinator.com/topcompanies/ https://www.ycombinator.com/topcompanies/
- dangus 7y ago“Mentoring” is a code word for “not working very hard.” I don’t have any particular admiration for someone so wealthy that “mentoring” is in their job description. Arguably the tech industry is (or was up until recently) so disruptive that any idiot with money could invest in it and come out ahead (the SoftBank strategy).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SandersAK 7y agoI agree that this article is a fluff piece but, unless you worked with him at YC or seen how he worked there, the idea that he wasn’t doing a lot to make YC successful is wrong. It’s not an exaggeration to say that PG’s work and insights changed venture funding and startups significantly. For better or worse! Generally agree that a lot of tech luminaries are overrated and often not qualified to speak on topics out of their field though.
- dangus 7y agoI guess my argument is that you could replace him with any number of the numerous reasonably above average performers at your company and the results would be the same. The difference is that none of your coworkers got to sell a company to Yahoo! at an inflated dot com era price to fund a venture capital firm. Sure, YC is a famous seed accelerator, but it’s also not unlike a number of other early stage investment firms that also provide mentoring and guidance to early stage founders. The success of these venture firms boils down to a math equation and a selection process, not any sort of unique secret sauce. It is a venture of owning capital and growing it, not of any sort of unique skill set.
- justinmeiners 7y agoIf had many paying subscriptions and stesfy growth how is that worthless? Do you perhaps mean the acquisition wasn't helpful to Yahoo?