3 ms·
Hierarchies suck. That's why early web "search engines" failed, the old hierarchical portals, and Google won (once it added a good sorting algorithm to the what
by oblio 7y ago
Hierarchies suck. That's why early web "search engines" failed, the old hierarchical portals, and Google won (once it added a good sorting algorithm to the what the initial search engines returned).
The UI is one input and the "computer" figures out the rest.
Regular users don't want/understand hierarchies, they get easily confused. They also don't want to organize things themselves, see the many failed attempts at tagging files, websites, images, etc. manually.
- perl4ever 7y agoEvery time this is mentioned, people say "shut up shut up shut up, nobody wants hierarchies". Obviously it's dogma. But if you have to keep saying it... I am probably not a "regular user", but I got a job about a year ago defined by and intended for regular users, and one of the major parts of it was managing emails in a departmental account, using (you guessed it) hierarchical folders, and another was managing project documents in SharePoint, using (what appear to be) hierarchical folders. I'm aware that people will tell you not to do the latter in SharePoint, that it's not really designed to be used like a filesystem, just use lists, etc. But purely from an anthropological viewpoint, I see how people shove everything on a shared drive, and then they try to move it to something like SharePoint and recreate a folder structure. So, you know, it's not about what I want, but it's an objective fact people do want hierarchies, even when other people don't want them to. Google is pervasive, but it's not all of computing.