5 ms·
Part of the reason law firms are resistant to technological change is that they are paid hourly (for the most part) and therefore do not yearn for efficiencies
by gnicholas 7y ago
Part of the reason law firms are resistant to technological change is that they are paid hourly (for the most part) and therefore do not yearn for efficiencies. If it increases efficiency, they will literally lose money in hourly billings.
- eganist 7y agoWell if you think about it, the original concept behind Atrium was to kill a business model. Kinda difficult to effectively pay lawyers to shoot their own feet.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- freepor 7y agoWell if you can pay 1% of the lawyers 10x the lifetime earnings they would get in BigLaw, they will happily destroy the business model for yo.
- Barrin92 7y agothis doesn't seem like a strong argument because this is just basic market competition. Even though a law firm being more efficient would lose hourly billing they would quickly grow more clients by providing a cheaper service. The lawfirm itself has no particular incentive to operate inefficiently. I think the much more plausible explanation is that a lot of these alleged 'productivity tools' don't add that much productivity.
- speedplane 7y ago> this doesn't seem like a strong argument because this is just basic market competition. Even though a law firm being more efficient would lose hourly billing they would quickly grow more clients by providing a cheaper service. The lawfirm itself has no particular incentive to operate inefficiently. As a factual matter, you are quite wrong. Law firms rarely get reprimanded for over-billing, and in fact, the opposite can be true. When a lawyer bills 2X more than a competitor, they can say that they just did a 2X better job, were more thorough, etc. Lawsuits are rarely repetitive, as the facts and legal principles applied vary widely, so it's very difficult to determine what's the correct amount of time to spend on something. Worse, firms that develop reputations for big bills, can even attract big bet-the-company cases where clients can justify paying top-dollar. The economic principal behind this is that legal services are not a typical "commodity", so standard market principles are not as effective. If you can turn a legal service into a commodity (such as LegalZoom has some parts of the law), you can be much more effective.
- adharmad 7y agoCan they not be more efficient and still bill the same hours? What is stopping them from improving their internal efficiency but still pocketing the same amount of money?
- terminalcommand 7y agoYou definitely can, most of the times you can’t collect all the hours you put in. Client pays what it pays and the rest is written off. It’s the senior’s job to manage the ratio of billed hours to collected hours. If you can and want to bill more to a client, you simply review the matter covering more depth or let the work be done by more senior lawyers who have a better hourly rate. Big-law collects all the client is ready to spend on legal services. The more you spend, the better service you’ll get. If you suspect foulplay in billables, review the job narratives and raise a complaint.
- speedplane 7y ago> You definitely can, most of the times you can’t collect all the hours you put in. Client pays what it pays and the rest is written off. It’s the senior’s job to manage the ratio of billed hours to collected hours. I am telling you --from experience, not theory-- that many lawyers are resistant to time-saving tools. Not all of them, but many of them. They rarely voice out-loud that their concern is about reduced billables, and will instead make absurd arguments that the time-saving tools decrease quality. Simple real life example: we were selling a very simple bulk download tool to a law firm. Instead of clicking a link and downloading a document many times, this tool would download many in batch and put them in a zip folder. They raised the objection saying "how do we know it downloaded everything", even though the zip file also had an excel listing all the documents that were downloaded, the source of where they came from, and any errors in downloading them.
- speedplane 7y ago> Can they not be more efficient and still bill the same hours? What is stopping them from improving their internal efficiency but still pocketing the same amount of money? As a lawyer, if you read and understand a document in 10 minutes and bill an hour of time for it, that's lying and you can lose your bar license over it. However, if you read that same document very slowly and carefully over a full hour, then you are considered a high quality detail-oriented attorney.
- gnicholas 7y ago> they would quickly grow more clients by providing a cheaper service Law firm prestige is measured in part by billing rates, which firms almost never (except 2008) lower. If a firm lowered rates for any reason, associates would start getting worried/jumping ship. I'm not saying it's rational, just that the field is prestige-based, and associates would freak if they saw their billing rate drop. It would be seen as a harbinger of lower salaries or lousy bonuses on the horizon, no matter how the firm spun it.