4 ms·
This happened less than 2 months after a "pivot to tools": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22040238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22040238
by minimaxir 7y ago
This happened less than 2 months after a "pivot to tools": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22040238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22040238
- gumby 7y agoNever really seen a "pivot to tools" work (after I tried it with one company, and it failed, I started noticing when others tried it too).
- nharada 7y agoWhy do you think it never pans out?
- m3kw9 7y agoProb cuz you are doing less with the same customers
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- itronitron 7y agoUsing a tool often requires a lot more work than using (consuming) a service.
- evanrich 7y agoSlack is an example
- gumby 7y agoGood example! It wasn't quite what I thinking as it isn't really "our game startup failed; let's sell game tools" but still it counts.
- mbesto 7y agoI see business services companies build tools in their vertical industry and become successful all of the time. You just can't take venture funding.
- gumby 7y agoThe question is over a pivot from "I'm going to provide product/service X at a profit due to my tool T" to "Well, I couldn't sell X so I'll sell T to other people who want X". If you couldn't make a go of it, is it really likely others will, or if they can that they will want your tool T to do so? This is different from either providing a service and successfuly using your own software to do so or providing a service and developing as well tools specifically for your customers. Slack was suggested by another poster as a company that pulled this off, though I'm not sure the communication tool was considered crucial to the game business.
- mbesto 7y agoFair. I guess it depends on what you determine as a success. 37signals was probably somewhat successful as a dev shop, but obviously not nearly as successful as a project management software one.
- g_p 7y agoIn the case of Atrium, it also sounded like their "pivot to tools" was trying to take many of their existing (ex) employees on the legal side, and convert them into clients of the tools. While the legal and tools companies were together, I'm sure the lawyers enjoyed the shiny tools. But after the "pivot", with the lawyers seemingly going it alone with some of the former clients, it seems likely to me that Atrium (the tool) just wasn't offering enough of a value proposition to make the tool company profitable. Venture money needs massive growth. Selling a tool to lawyers will get an amount of money per month proportionate to the number of fee-earners. And from the sounds of things, their tools weren't exactly going to be irreplaceable. Anyone got any direct insight as to if the tools themselves were compelling but the pivot failed, or if the tools didn't deliver?
- aresant 7y agoI know several including housecall which is now housecall pro
- enra 7y agoThe pivot never got started, they just announced it. Atrium was continuing their existing model/had the lawyers employed until March 1st.