3 ms·
From the article: > In contrast to Enlightenment thinkers like Thomas Jefferson or Immanuel Kant, anti-foundationalists argue that there are no self-evident tr
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
From the article:
> In contrast to Enlightenment thinkers like Thomas Jefferson or Immanuel Kant, anti-foundationalists argue that there are no self-evident truths or inalienable rights, and indeed, no such thing as a stable, discoverable human nature, rational or otherwise, “for human beings make themselves up as they go along.”
That is what at least one branch of postmodernism (Rorty) says. But in mathematics, without axioms you can't prove anything. In the same way, if nothing is self-evident, then nothing can be proven. (If I recall correctly, I'm stealing this line from C.S. Lewis in "The Abolition of Man".) I think that's what's so hard about postmodernism - they say you can't prove anything, and in fact you don't know anything.
But the same thing is true of the postmodernists themselves - they also don't know anything, and can't prove anything, including the claims of postmodernism. They can't even prove that you can't prove anything! (That doesn't disprove postmodernism. But if they are just spouting theories of which they can't actually be sure and that they can't prove, then they can give you no reason why you should take them seriously.)
- repsilat 7y agoI think it's pragmatic. Most "arguments" outside of maths and computer programming aren't made through chains of bullet-proof logic. They're more often made by analogy, by authority, by appeals to shared but not universal values, and so on. As I see it, they're interested in coming up with satisfactory answers when perfect ones aren't available. If we wait until we have a universal and unimpeachable answer for what to have for dinner we'll all starve. But "proving" that perfect answers to certain questions can't be obtained, or that some imperfect answers can be satisfactory, is somewhat beside the point -- they're not in the business of proof. "Proving" things is a modernist fetish, and trite paradoxes around nothing being universal are mostly just cute jokes for entertaining undergrads :-p.
- danharaj 7y agoMathematical activity doesn't proceed from axioms. Axioms proceed from mathematical activity. The philosophy that grew out of the axiomatization of mathematics in the early 20th century never really took root in its culture or practice. If you want to read a philosophical account of mathematics as it is actively practiced today, Synthetic Philosophy of Contemporary Mathematics by Zalamea (a practicing mathematician) is good. It is far more sympathetic to postmodernism than you would think. And for an account of modern logic by a logician in a postmodern vein, La Fantome de la Transparence by Girard is gr8. Only in French atm.