3 ms·

Before we even get into the role of expert peer reviewers, does the article pass basic tests of authenticity, let alone extraordinary claims requiring extraordi

Before we even get into the role of expert peer reviewers, does the article pass basic tests of authenticity, let alone extraordinary claims requiring extraordinary proof? The third author of the referenced paper does have a page at Harvard, here: http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~mcgeoch/index.html http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~mcgeoch/index.html where she says she is at the "Department of Molecular and Cellular Biology, Harvard University" but she's not listed as faculty in that department here: https://www.mcb.harvard.edu/faculty/faculty-profiles/ https://www.mcb.harvard.edu/faculty/faculty-profiles/ Could be a student... but do a search for Malcolm. W. McGeoch, Sergei Dikler, Julie E. M. McGeoch from Plex Corporation, Bruker Scientific LLC and Harvard University and you will start to wonder if these people even know their names have been used in this article. Shame on phys.org for not calling the author for a quote or doing any other legwork to convince me this is anything other than a UFO hoax or the output of a paper-writing AI. It could be, but ...journalist please.

ampersandy29 7y ago
Some cursory search shows papers published by Julie E. M. McGeoch on related topics over the last 30 years, many of which are also co-authored by Malcom McGeoch of Plex Corporation, who I assume is of some relation (significant other or relative). I admittedly don't know a ton about academic publishing, but from my outside position, it seems unlikely that this report is fraudulently attributed—though it's certainly possible that I'm missing something.
T-A 7y ago
You can look up McGeoch, Julie here: https://www.directory.harvard.edu/ https://www.directory.harvard.edu/ Associate of the Department of Molecular and Cellular Biology. Previous papers on arxiv (just click the author name on the abstract page): https://arxiv.org/search/astro-ph?searchtype=author&query=McGeoch%2C+J+E+M https://arxiv.org/search/astro-ph?searchtype=author&query=Mc... I am all for healthy skepticism, but insinuating a hoax based on an ad hominem without even spending a few seconds to do a quick check is not.

ampersandy29 7y ago

Some cursory search shows papers published by Julie E. M. McGeoch on related topics over the last 30 years, many of which are also co-authored by Malcom McGeoch of Plex Corporation, who I assume is of some relation (significant other or relative). I admittedly don't know a ton about academic publishing, but from my outside position, it seems unlikely that this report is fraudulently attributed—though it's certainly possible that I'm missing something.

T-A 7y ago

You can look up McGeoch, Julie here: https://www.directory.harvard.edu/ https://www.directory.harvard.edu/ Associate of the Department of Molecular and Cellular Biology. Previous papers on arxiv (just click the author name on the abstract page): https://arxiv.org/search/astro-ph?searchtype=author&query=McGeoch%2C+J+E+M https://arxiv.org/search/astro-ph?searchtype=author&query=Mc... I am all for healthy skepticism, but insinuating a hoax based on an ad hominem without even spending a few seconds to do a quick check is not.