5 ms·
I've edited the post accordingly, it was a brain fart moment... But thanks for your sincere feedback
by airstrike 7y ago
I've edited the post accordingly, it was a brain fart moment... But thanks for your sincere feedback
- lawrenceyan 7y agoI'm 100% understanding of brain farts. It's just that to do so on something as fundamental and basic as monetary versus fiscal policy, to me feels like, a mistake a non-layman wouldn't make. It's not like you can chalk it up to an issue with similar spelling either. 'Monetary' and 'fiscal' are written completely differently.
- thenewwazoo 7y agoMy grandmother occasionally calls her children by each others' names. She's done it her entire life. She even mixes up her son's name and her daughters'. What she named her children is "fundamental and basic", too, and she's certainly an expert in how they're named. Heck, they're not even spelled similarly. Please help keep HN a nicer place by giving others the benefit of the doubt.
- wpietri 7y agoI'm not quite following. Are you only expecting experts to comment here? If so, are you an expert in the frequency and type of textual errors and how that relates to expertise?
- lawrenceyan 7y agoThe issue is when you have what currently is the top comment for this article, written in a manner which implies that the writer knows what they are talking about (i.e. /u/airstrike using terminology like "after spending more time than I'm willing to admit listening to every finance talking head out there"). I'm calling into question /u/airstrike's legitimacy due to not being able to differentiate between monetary and fiscal policy in their explanation. This is because, you learn about what monetary and fiscal policy are very early on, like in an introductory economics course. It raises red flags when you are unable to differentiate the two. I mention the spelling of 'monetary' versus 'fiscal' and how different they are in order to argue that it's unlikely /u/airstrike made the mistake because of a grammatical error or say because they were typing too fast. I apologize if I sound harsh here, but I think it's important that things like these are called out. While /u/airstrike might not purposely be trying to do it here in his/her comment, this is exactly the kind of thing that leads to misinformation spreading.
- chrsm 7y agoHow about you take his apology and move on?
- lawrenceyan 7y agoMy response was to /u/wpietri who asked for a clarification.
- wpietri 7y agoI was actually pointing out the contradiction between your supposed standard and your behavior. But fair enough, it was phrased as a question. Which, it turns out, you did not actually answer, so if you were trying to clarify things I don't think you succeeded.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 7y agoI think there's an enormous difference between "I have some polite questions about your level of expertise" and "I will repeatedly jump on a possibly-innocent error". I will note that airstrike is not "unable to differentiate the two". They have quite clearly gone on to demonstrate that ability. It is important to make sure false information doesn't circulate. But I don't think that excuses being "harsh".
- lawrenceyan 7y agoAhh, I see. I think I understand the confusion now. I believe our primary disagreement here lies in the fact that you don't see /u/airstrike not differentiating between fiscal and monetary policy in his/her original comment, as a major red flag, whereas from my perspective I do. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
- 7y ago