3 ms·
At Robinhood, you're not the customer. You're the product.[1] Robinhood makes their money by selling order flow to high-frequency traders. Robinhood doesn't cha
by Animats 7y ago
At Robinhood, you're not the customer. You're the product.[1]
Robinhood makes their money by selling order flow to high-frequency traders. Robinhood doesn't charge commissions, but the price is slightly worse.
[1] https://seekingalpha.com/article/4212397-robinhood-high-frequency-trading-scandal-plot-thickens https://seekingalpha.com/article/4212397-robinhood-high-freq...
- gmm1990 7y agoHow do you think most brokerages fill orders? I'd rather get filled at the best price possible, which I assume a high frequency firm would be able to do better than some other filling method. Pretty sure most brokerages do this anyway.
- gmm1990 7y agoSorry thinking about this more, I guess the actual best price at the stock exchanges would be preferable
- tptacek 7y agoInternalizers can quote better prices than the exchange NBBO; you don't have to guess: when you're buying, the lower price is the better one.
- intuitionist 7y agoReg NMS prevents HFTs from filling your order outside of the NBBO. if anything you’ll get slightly more favorable prices from a market maker, since they know you’re a retail trader who’s not going to run them over.
- gmm1990 7y agoYeah that makes sense then. I have been using Robinhood cause I figured it wouldn't matter anyway the latency differences between click trading and their algos are so large. But I won't be after the outage today.
- tptacek 7y agoThis is... not a good analysis. It's directionally correct but not for the reason you say it is. Virtually all brokers are rebated for routing orders to HFTs. HFTs dominate retail order execution. HFTs pay brokerages for access to their order flow, because that order flow is uninformed and safe to quote narrow spreads for. Like other brokerages, Robinhood makes money on net interest from cash holdings and stock lending fees (it helps that Robinhood encourages people to buy meme stocks with a lot of short interest). Unlike other brokerages, Robinhood also encourages options trading, which are more lucrative for market makers. You sort of are the product at Robinhood, but it's not really because Robinhood is doing bog standard order routing that every other broker does too.
- junar 7y agoNo, that's incredibly misleading. > Headlines like Robinhood Gets Almost Half Its Revenue in Controversial Bargain With High-Speed Traders are virtually meaningless, as the above discussion of other monetization options should make clear. At scale, once their userbase actually has material cash in their accounts on any given day, they’ll likely make net interest, but pre-scale they may not even have the treasury function to do the work required to earn it safely. It’s a commentary on how low their revenue is (growth-stage startup optimizing for reach over revenue, film at 11), not a commentary on how beholden they are to Wall Street. https://www.kalzumeus.com/2019/6/26/how-brokerages-make-money/ https://www.kalzumeus.com/2019/6/26/how-brokerages-make-mone...