4 ms·
I've largely stopped trying to say anything like "I do x because of y cultural influence." Like: "My mom's German, so..." I often have no way of knowing if my m
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I've largely stopped trying to say anything like "I do x because of y cultural influence." Like: "My mom's German, so..." I often have no way of knowing if my mom does that thing because it's a widespread thing in German culture or if that's just a thing my mom does and it's got little or nothing to do with her being born and raised in Germany.
(I've run into Germans who do the opposite of something my mom does that I thought was representative of German culture and been told their way was the norm in Germany. I threw my hands in the air and made my peace with "not everything my mom does is representative of most Germans.")
We routinely think X person is from Y culture, so X person is representative of Y culture and it's frequently just absolutely not true at all. Fascinating that this fact leads to the works of essentially cultural outcasts coming home again and being embraced as "one of us" and someone we are proud to claim as a representative of our culture when they were originally "that loser we want nothing to do with, so they had to leave the country to succeed."
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> We routinely think X person is from Y culture, so X person is representative of Y culture and it's frequently just absolutely not true at all. It's trickier than that. It's almost always true. But culture has many, many dimensions. Nobody can be typical in every dimension. But if you choose a cultural element at random, and then examine a person's expression of that element, you're very likely to find that they are indeed typical of their native culture.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoMy father spent 26.5 years in the Army. He spent 18.5 years overseas in various places. I've thought long and hard about such things. TLDR of a few decades of contemplating such: People tend to move elsewhere because they don't fit in and aren't really happy where they are. The Pizza Effect explicitly describes things that got popular elsewhere first before being embraced and celebrated back home. This fits with my observation that it's the "misfits" who tend to leave. This includes my mother who left home as a teenager, moved to another country and never went home again. She had excellent reasons for doing so. This is not intended to suggest that she was wrong for failing to go along to get along. I think a lot of people that leave have high standards, refuse to compromise them and also don't want to fight with people they care about. So they leave to live by a value of "live and let live." Which might actually help explain why the Pizza Effect exists. If your best and brightest get tired of your shit, go elsewhere with their good ideas and market them as "a cool thing from my home country" and it gets successful, this could very well explain why this happens at all. I have read that real change only happens when the old guard dies out. Most people never change their minds and actively work to suppress the success of people who are a threat to their position at the top of the pecking order. So real change only happens when they drop dead, thereby making space for newcomers with new ideas to take their place.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI like the phrase “the knowledge quest proceeds funeral by funeral”.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI really like that phrasing. I had not heard it before. I did reply to you earlier, but I'm running a fever, short of sleep and angsting about a pandemic. So I deleted it, cuz reasons. I do appreciate you chiming in.
- twic 7y agoI hadn't heard the "knowledge quest" bit before, but the general origin of that (including "funeral by funeral") is dug into here: https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/09/25/progress/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2017/09/25/progress/
- samatman 7y agoThis describes some migration, but by no means all of it, and by sheer head-count is probably not typical. For America, the case I'm most familiar with, people tended to settle in large waves, and start in ethnic enclaves in coastal cities. The first person to move was probably a misfit, but was followed by dozens of cousins who were just not thriving, due to local conditions (nothing to inherit being a very popular one). These enclaves had, and have, dual forces of assimilation into the baseline culture, and the natural attempt to rebuild what is best about the home they've left behind. Point being that you don't have to be dissatisfied with e.g. Sicilian culture, if you're offered an opportunity to move to New York, keep speaking Italian, and have a piece of the promised American Dream if you work hard, at least for your kids. It's an attractive offer, if you don't stand to inherit and can't find a job. Doesn't imply you don't want to keep eating what you already like.
- 7y ago
- cortesoft 7y agoOne of my favorite takes on the limitations of our desire to have clean categories for everything: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/aMHq4mA2PHSM2TMoH/the-categories-were-made-for-man-not-man-for-the-categories https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/aMHq4mA2PHSM2TMoH/the-catego...
- rfrey 7y agoThe one thing I learned from the Ukrainian and Polish elders in my life: the people in the next village are idiots and have no idea how to make proper pierogis.
- thomk 7y agoHahahah! Hell yeah!
- throwaway17_17 7y agoThe real question is how the Polish/Ukrainian elders feel about those Ukrainian/Polish elders and those weird things they eat, because ‘those sure as hell are NOT pierogis!!’ Or worse ask the Romanian elders in my life and they’ll gladly tell you no one but there mother makes colțunași right, let alone foreigners (which of course includes the family up the street).
- fit2rule 7y agoI have a theory about language, which I've formulated by living all over the world for 50 years. It goes like this: If you have two villages, maybe separated by a lake, or by a mountain, and one village has goats, the other has sheep - or maybe one of these villages has brown goats and the other just white goats - or maybe there are a couple of cows in one and a coal mine at the other - then it doesn't matter how close these villages are, they will fight for their own dialect, which will eventually become a new language. (Austria problems.)
- dhosek 7y agoI found when I visited Prague a few years back that the Czech cuisine that I grew up with had apparently managed to be completely unmodified from the original in its American version. The same cannot be said for Mexican cuisine in the US. I suspect part of that might be that very few people without Czech heritage (or Czech-adjacent, it seems the cuisine is fairly uniform across much of the old Austro-Hungarian empire) eat Czech food in the US.
- sk5t 7y agoMy theory is that the descendant generations from immigrants to America don't care to modify the family recipes at all, to keep traditions going, and there are generally not any outside influences to change this, so the food stays frozen in time from 100-200 years ago. Like, your Irish American neighbors are not going to weigh in with ideas on how to improve or evolve the squash strudel. For what it's worth, Germans from the Bohemian/Sudetengau area make some dishes much the same as Czech. There's no substitute for bread dumplings with pork and sauerkraut! Or plum dumplings the one month in the year the right kind of plums are available. But when you get to other areas of Germany, they all have different ideas about how to make dumplings.
- fit2rule 7y agoForeign foods are modified by the locals according to a lack of ingredients, and on the basis of the local palates.. in Austria, for example, I've gotten used to eating ultra-bland Asian or Mexican food, since Austrians rarely have the disposition to weather the more exotic spices.
- DonHopkins 7y agoTexMex was imported to Prague as CzechMex, which was then exported back to Texas, or course: >“Excellent Czech-Mex in Prague” https://www.think.cz/people/1190-think-innerview-federico-salas-mexican-ambassador-to-the-czech-republic https://www.think.cz/people/1190-think-innerview-federico-sa... http://londoncosmopolitan.blogspot.com/2009/02/praha-czech-republic.html http://londoncosmopolitan.blogspot.com/2009/02/praha-czech-r... >Overall, Prague is a must if you’re going to be in Europe, just be aware of the time of year you go. We had a surprisingly decent Mexican meal at a place called CzechMex. We also ate a ton of goulash which was a tasty, hearty way to stay comfortable in Prague’s blistering, windy February cold. Prague Castle and the Charles Bridge are the main sites and you can easily complete the whole trip in no more than two days. -- Keenan https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g274707-d694824-r18339031-Restaurace_Jama-Prague_Bohemia.html https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g274707-d694824-... >Think Innerview: Federico Salas, Mexican Ambassador to the Czech Republic >THINK: So, where do you go for Mexican cuisine in Prague? >SALAS: My House. It’s the best place to have Mexican food. I don’t cook but fortunately enough, there is a person who has been cooking at the residence for 15 years now. She cooks Czech very well, but she also knows how to cook Mexican. So we’re developing a new style of cuisine which I’m calling CzechMex. >THINK: Have you tried some of the Mexican restaurants here? >Yes, but the places in Prague are more in the nature of TexMex, less traditional. Good Mexican food is not just about the spices, it’s also the nature of knowing how to mix the ingredients. The one thing that does surprise me is that Mexican Food is really popular – authentic or not. And it seems that people are drinking more and more tequila...which is a good thing. http://czechmexbakery.com/ http://czechmexbakery.com/ >Czech-Mex Bakery & Cafe is famous for it's amazing breakfast and brunch menu with Texas and Czech tastes. We're kind of a big deal at lunch time in Corpus Christi. Come see what the fuss is about! >Best Kolaches in Texas. We've been accused of that title. And Texas is a big place. Our delicious kolaches are what made us a Corpus Christi favorite! They bring out the Czech-Mex in all of us! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolach
- mihaaly 7y agoI believe this kind of over simplification or representation exists for many aspects of life, this is how our brain copes with complex matters (I believe). Which I understand but do not like or willing to accept when it comes to me as it is being lazy (or dumb) behavior sparing the observer from the job of real discovery of the subject at hand leading to prejudice or much worse destructive practices (e.g. racism).
- Gibbon1 7y agoReminds me in the late 1940's the USAF was losing pilots and jets to 'human factors'. They thought to solve it by hiring a statistician to measure their pilots and determine the average pilot. The better the design cockpits and controls around. That guy found there wasn't an average pilot. You have more combinations of foot/hand size, arm/leg length, torso's etc than you have pilots. With culture ultimately everyone's some sort of deviant.
- pjc50 7y agoI think a lot of people lean on saying that they're doing X "because of tradition" because it's socially easier than saying that you like it yourself. Vague memory of a story of someone who was walking across America (or similar giant arduous travel project) who found that, if he said he was doing it because he wanted to, he got looked at weird, but if he said he was doing it for a bet everyone understood immediately. The latter anchors him in society, while having your own preferences makes you a loose cannon. This leads to people travelling the world looking for a tradition to adopt, because that's "easier" than starting your own tradition.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI crossed the country from Georgia to California while homeless. I walked a lot and accepted rides. People routinely wanted to impose some larger explanation, like "Are you doing a fundraiser? Are you trying to raise awareness for something?" "I'm too poor to travel by planes, trains or automobiles" is an alien concept and large parts of this country go out of their way to make it difficult to walk somewhere. Walking as a means of travel ought to be some kind of basic right, but it's actually illegal in many places because you can't walk on the limited access roads and there are no other roads through there.
- pjc50 7y ago> I crossed the country from Georgia to California while homeless I'd just like to say without snark or detraction that this is an amazing achievement. Must have taken most of a year?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNah. Rides covered most of it. We walked 10 to 17 miles a day and rides could cover a lot more than that in very little time. I was evicted December 31st. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to me. It was a three day weekend and I slept in a tent and I wasn't initially planning on quitting my job. After three days in a tent, I felt better than I had in years and decided I wasn't going back to my job to re-expose myself to more Sick Building Syndrome stuff, so I emailed my "I quit" notice to my boss and me and my sons left town on foot. We arrived in Port Aransas, Texas about January 15th because someone had picked us up in Florida who had a flexible schedule. She said she would drive us an hour, but she really enjoyed talking with me and said something like "I'd drive you farther if I could afford the gas" and I said I would pay for a tank of gas. So she made a couple of phone calls to clear her schedule for the next day and drove us to Houston, Texas. The next day, some very, very sincerely Christian lady stopped to pick us up and I explained we were heading to Port Aransas and she too just dropped everything and drove us to Port Aransas. We stayed in Port Aransas for a month. The goal was to not freeze to death or lose toes to frostbite while crossing the Rockies in the dead of winter. We left Port Aransas February 15th and arrived in downtown San Diego about six weeks later in late March. Actual travel time was about 7.5 or 8 weeks total. Even with a month in Port Aransas, we were in San Diego in under three months. To be fair, we did not start at the coast in Georgia. We started on the other Georgia border, up against Alabama.