6 ms·
The had problem of consciousness is related to neither neuroscience or physics, far from being a central problem in either. It's a central problem in philosophy
by whatshisface 7y ago
The had problem of consciousness is related to neither neuroscience or physics, far from being a central problem in either. It's a central problem in philosophy.
- jamesrcole 7y agoHow do you know it is unrelated to neuroscience? If you were to ask me whether I think neuroscience currently has any understanding of the hard problem of consciousness, I would say that I don't think they do. But it's still related to neuroscience.
- robbrown451 7y agoI notice that on the wikipedia page, an equal number of philosophers and cognitive neuroscientists are mentioned. For instance: "The existence of a "hard problem" is controversial. It has been accepted by philosophers of mind such as Joseph Levine, Colin McGinn, and Ned Block and cognitive neuroscientists such as Francisco Varela, Giulio Tononi, and Christof Koch. However, its existence is disputed by philosophers of mind such as Daniel Dennett, Massimo Pigliucci, and Keith Frankish and cognitive neuroscientists such as Stanislas Dehaene, Bernard Baars, and Antonio Damasio." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_problem_of_consciousness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_problem_of_consciousness
- whatshisface 7y agoIf a neuroscientist had an opinion about who should get elected president this year, that would not make the presidential election a neurological issue.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoIf the a hard problem is real, then it is a neuroscience issue. If it does not exist, then the illusion of it is a neuroscience issue.
- whatshisface 7y agoWhat if consciousness real but not a neuroscience issue? If you want a thought experiment to illustrate that, imagine a VR world where the inhabitants are connected in with headsets. Nothing inside the world will explain why it feels to everyone like experiences are being exported out of it.
- robbrown451 7y ago"imagine a VR world" I don't see how this contributes any insights into the issue. How is that "world" any different from a real world experience, relevant to this issue? I mean, nothing in Disneyland's Pirates of the Caribbean ride explains "why it feels to everyone like experiences are being exported out of it" either.
- whatshisface 7y ago>nothing in Disneyland's Pirates of the Caribbean ride explains "why it feels to everyone like experiences are being exported out of it" either. Yeah, exactly. There's no way to tell if neuroscience is just the "Pirates of the Caribbean" ride through which something else is getting pulled through on boats. Is there any evidence one way or the other? What would evidence look like? I think it is beyond the reach of science because there is no experiment you could ever do that would illuminate it. Something that can only be resolved by discussing the options and choosing which one feels the most reasonable is philosophy, and not science.
- chr1 7y agoIn all cases it is a Math issue. Either there exists some effective computation that would produce behavior similar to the behavior of conscious being, and could be performed in VR world too, or computation would require exponential resources, or (in the most unlikely case) such computation would not exist, and it would be possible to show why it cannot exist. Neuroscience and Physics can help to find the rules for that computation. And Philosophy can have fun talking about what lies beyond unknown.
- robbrown451 7y agoNo, but that's not the point. The fact that many of them are quoted or referenced suggests that their opinions are relevant, at least to Wikipedia editors. Most other articles on the subject continually reference neuroscience and neuroscientists. Regardless, not everything fits into neat little boxes. I would personally be more interested in the views of a neuroscientist on the matter, but then again I'd expect them to be likely to dismiss it as not being a problem at all. I'd also be interested in the views of someone who works with AI and the like. Personally I think the problem will be "solved" as soon as we have sufficiently advanced conversational assistants and we just start assuming they are conscious because they seem like they are. I think having that sort of thing in our daily lives will dramatically change people's intuitive perspective on the issue.
- whatshisface 7y ago>I would personally be more interested in the views of a neuroscientist on the matter, Some neuroscientists having an interesting take on the election does not imply that elections are a neurological topic. Philosophy is open to contributions from amateurs.
- perl4ever 7y agoWhen and how did philosophy undergo professionalization? "Professionalization tends to result in establishing acceptable qualifications, one or more professional associations to recommend best practice and to oversee the conduct of members of the profession, and some degree of demarcation of the qualified from unqualified amateurs (that is, professional certification). It is also likely to create "occupational closure", closing the profession to entry from outsiders, amateurs and the unqualified."
- whatshisface 7y agoThat's a huge question, but I think it happened in the 20th century during the academic boom.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThere aren't many problems that go away just by being declared not-hard - or in extremis, not-a-real-problem. Especially not by being declared not-a-real-problem by the problem itself.
- erikerikson 7y agoAs the philosophers have it, all fields are subfields of philosophy. If this is so, the problem in neuroscience and physics is by definition the same problem (perhaps with different scopes) and included in philosophy. However, I'm not left feeling like I've gained any knowledge from recognizing this. It is so that it has been an important problem in philosophy but do you expect anyone to be surprised by that knowledge?
- oarabbus_ 7y ago>As the philosophers have it, all fields are subfields of philosophy. Seems a bit self-serving. Surely the physicists could make a claim that all fields (including philosophy) are subfields of physics.
- evunveot 7y agoIs consciousness an emergent property of brains or are brains an emergent property of consciousness? That's the question.
- naasking 7y agoNo, because philosophy deals with any question, like "what is mathematics?", or "is there an objective standard for beauty?" which is completely outside the scope of physics. Physics is necessarily more limited as it's bound by the scientific process. In fact, the soundness of the scientific method itself is a philosophical argument, as it cannot be scientifically demonstrable without assuming the conclusion.