3 ms·
The older I get, the less I like key chording. This is particularly exacerbated by the lack of a common key chording scheme between Windows, Linux, and OSX. It
by falcolas 7y ago
The older I get, the less I like key chording. This is particularly exacerbated by the lack of a common key chording scheme between Windows, Linux, and OSX. It becomes a mental stutter as I have to constantly override my muscle memory. It's probably why I like VIM editor schemes so much - there's significantly less chording required.
I've also noticed the preference come up when playing games. Ideally, I would simply assign additional abilities to modified keys, but for the life of me, it's just simpler to assign them, one to one, to keys on the keyboard. My hand needs to move around the keyboard a bit more, but it has to contort a lot less.
Also, it's somewhat telling that some the fastest typists in the world don't use shift - they use caps lock.
ref. http://www.seanwrona.com/typing.php http://www.seanwrona.com/typing.php the final paragraph
- Timpy 7y agoI don't doubt the report that Wrona is using caps lock instead of shift, but it baffles me. How did he manage to make that faster? I only use left shift, which is pretty similar except he has to hit twice as many keys to accomplish the same thing.
- falcolas 7y agoI've mucked around with it, so speaking only from that mucking it offers two things: Your hand is not anchored to the shift button. You can use one finger for the first press of capslock, and another for the second, based on where the previous and next letters are (this is a reference to the typist using any finger to hit any letter). Using shift is still three actions: for the shift button it's a press and hold followed by a timed release, plus a press of the target letter. Given this, the "press press press" rhythm matches the rest of the typing flow better than "hold press release".
- clarry 7y agoBetter compromise is sticky shift for when you just need to capitalize one letter. Then it's just press press.
- falcolas 7y agoI would agree, but that's not a feature available by default on most (any?) keyboards. You'd have to enable it via driver software. Since we're looking at competitive typists (what a world, eh?), they're probably not allowed such things when being measured.
- Timpy 7y agoI don't buy this answer. If the shift button is three actions then the capslock is four. Shift: Press -> hold -> release Lock: Press -> release -> press -> release Both cases require timing. I'm not convinced he's faster because of capslock, he seems to be faster in spite of it. I also use a hybrid typing style. For example, the word "server". The first time I strike the "e" with my middle finger and the second "e" is with my ring finger, freeing my middle finger to type the final "r" because my index finger is still at the lower row after typing "v". Surely he uses this style of non-traditional touch typing for words like "Azure, Qatar, Zaire," but I think the flexibility of finger choice is the secret to success, not the capslock key.
- falcolas 7y agoSo, I think the bigger difference is that there is no timing required on the release (short of "don't trigger auto-repeat"). Just as we (assumption alert) don't care about the timing of releasing the letter or number keys while typing, they don't worry about the release timing of the "shift/capslock" key when they're typing. To them, it's just like typing 'wow' or anything else with a repeating letter. I also imagine it makes typing out acroynyms a lot simpler as well. For example, I hold down left shift when I type NASA (left shift since I hit the 'n' with my right hand), and contort my left hand while being sure not to release shift to finish the word. In any case, it's mostly my own conjecture - day-to-day I can't type very accurately without relying on coming back to home; without using the same fingers for the same letters all the time.
- tartoran 7y agoI love key cording but use it on actions I am likely to repeat thousands of times if not more. Yes, they are all inconsistent between systems but how many times do you switch systems? And even if that happens on a daily basis, say use one program from one system and another one from a different system, it is still a net gain to learn the shortcuts for things that are likely to be used a lot. I get tripped off a bit when switching keyboards, between desktop and laptop. Still, it is worth the effort IMO.
- falcolas 7y ago> how many times do you switch systems Daily. Am I ever thankful that VIM is (mostly) the same across OSes. :/ Work: OSx Play: Windows Hobby: OSx terminal (effectively Linux) The bigger problem for me is that muscle memory between OSes is broken by something as simple as "how to do I get to the head (or tail) of the current line I'm on?" On Windows, it's Home/End. OSx is Cmd+Left/Right. Terminal, it's Ctrl+A/E (or Home/End, sometimes).
- ryukafalz 7y ago> OSx is Cmd+Left/Right. Terminal, it's Ctrl+A/E It’s also Ctrl+A/E most places in macOS - they’re Emacs keybindings, and lots of those work systemwide in macOS.
- franga2000 7y agoIs Home/End not universal? Besides one very broken shell session to some old embedded device over serial over telnet, I've never seen it not work. Isn't that the entire point of those keys existing?
- falcolas 7y agoHome, in a text entry box on OSX (including OSX native text editors), will take you (and your cursor) to the top of the document. End takes you to the bottom. On Windows, it takes you to the first character of the line you're currently working on.