2 ms·
I love this bit: >Nor could we make its inconsistency a reproach to it---are not men inconsistent too? Certainly women are, and politicians; and {53} even male
by simonh 7y ago
I love this bit:
>Nor could we make its inconsistency a reproach to it---are not men inconsistent too? Certainly women are, and politicians; and {53} even male non-politicians (121) contradict themselves sometimes, and a single inconsistency is enough to make a system inconsistent.
Not 'love' in an agreeing sense. Boy are we in different times now.
Agreed, I see no justification in assuming that human minds are consistent, in fact that seems self evidently not to be the case. Also just because a system is inconsistent, that doesn't mean it's incapable of generating or 'simulating' consistent systems. So we can conceive of a consistent system, apply it to problems and achieve all the advantages on consistency within some limited domain, while at the higher level being ourselves inconsistent. I see no reason why an automated system could not also do the same. This seems to me to break the argument completely, though I confess I'm no great philosopher and it's highly likely I'm missing something.