4 ms·
No, WhatsApp is not a dumpster fire. It might be a dumpster fire in ONE aspect the some of people care about, but: It is also one of the most responsive messen
by izacus 7y ago
No, WhatsApp is not a dumpster fire. It might be a dumpster fire in ONE aspect the some of people care about, but:
It is also one of the most responsive messengers out there. It's also one of the rare messengers what are reliable also on 2G and other very slow and spotty networks. It's also one of the rare messengers that includes video calls, voice calls and mutiple other features that make communication easy. It supports groups, invitations via links and multiple other features that make coordination of communities easy and seamless. And it also doesn't lose all your messaging history everytime your phone breaks.
Privacy crowd needs to start understanding this and needs to stop behaving like robots who don't understand WHY people use these apps although they might be "dumpster fire" in that one privacy aspect. And then move to fix Signal and other to make sure they're not "dumpster fire" in aspects the wide users actually care about.
- einpoklum 7y agoAlmost all of the features you mentioned are orthogonal to privacy; and in fact, other messaging clients have them, generally. As for keeping your messages - that is a trade-off between convenience and privacy. When people are aware of how their emails are being read, processed and used for spying they often (usually?) choose the privacy option.
- ailideex 7y agoI know many people that are well aware that google has access to their emails, all of them still use gmail. not sure who these people who usually choose privacy but I have yet to meet them.
- einpoklum 7y agoI'm not sure they are "well aware". Many of us have been told that, once or twice, so we're aware on some level, but we don't have the image in our mind the image of some person in the government being able to essentially sit at our mailbox and read our impolite, hateful or lewd messages.
- JakeDavis 7y agoNo one is disagreeing with any of those things, the thread was intended to be "from one aspect only". Here is something I wrote last year covering the issues you just raised. https://risky.biz/e2e-not-pointless-but/ https://risky.biz/e2e-not-pointless-but/
- izacus 7y agoThat's not what the title of this link implies. It says (right now): "WhatsApp is a dumpster fire." Not a security dumpster fire. Not a privacy dumpster fire. There's no qualifier in the title or the inital tweet. And WhatsApp is not a dumpster fire by any standard. I've edited my post to perhaps make this clearer.
- JakeDavis 7y agoIt's not a thesis or an article, I just shitposted seven things over a cup of coffee. See this article from last year if you want a more nuanced take: https://risky.biz/e2e-not-pointless-but/ https://risky.biz/e2e-not-pointless-but/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BigChiefSmokem 7y agoLooks like everything you post is a shit post... so why even do it? How many burner accounts do you have buddy?
- DCKing 7y agoWhatsapp adopted the Signal Protocol back in 2015. They unilaterally started enforcing E2E for billions of people despite not having any obvious business case for it. And they implemented it well: it's not optional, and completely seemless for all users. It just works in Whatsapp's otherwise great UX. Just the fact they have E2E alone makes Whatsapp better than any reasonably popular alternative - it's better from a privacy perspective than Facebook/Instagram messages, Google Hangouts, Telegram, email, sms text, RCS (not really popular but hey), Slack, Discord, Skype and any old school messengers. I mean I guess it kinda sucks that Whatsapp isn't Signal, or E2E Jabber, or E2E Matrix. But man, it could've been so much worse. It was so much worse. A global network accessible to and used by billions of people sending E2E encrypted messages was a privacy activist's wet dream 6 years ago. Whatsapp's move to E2E alone is amongst the most impactful changes in real-world privacy on the entire internet. Calling that a 'dumpster fire' because they transparently communicate they still know metadata about you really does make you seem like a robot. 'Dumpster fire' is not a synonym for 'has room to improve'. This kind of talk is par for the course on Twitter surely, but not it's not unreasonable to expect some flak for it.
- maxmunzel 7y ago> And it also doesn't lose all your messaging history everytime your phone breaks. There is no way to transfer Messages between iOS and Android or to backup messages in any way really - except of storing them plaintext at Google/Apple. I'd be really thankful, if anyone had some solution for this...
- Angostura 7y agoIt's more correct to say that WhatsApp's privacy model is a dumpster. The simplest way for it to improve would be to not demand full access to all contacts to work properly. I would be much happier if I could select the handful of contacts I want to actually WhatApp with and get the full experience, lik eother messaging apps. That would mess with their metadata collection, however.
- 72deluxe 7y agoIsn't email usable over 2G and spotty networks too? I find the VOIP calling on it laggy and delayed (listening to my wife's calls with her mum who hasn't realised that the default on her iPhone for calls is now WhatsApp as it has hijacked the default "phone" behaviour...)
- indigo945 7y agoHave you ever actually tried using email via 2G? It's a mess! You can maybe send (via SMTP), but IMAP just doesn't work because it has way too much back-and-forth talking between your phone and the server, which sucks with 2G latencies, and because it's just verbose in general, which sucks with 2G speeds.
- mping 7y agoWell SMS and voice calls work fine. For the res, most of the time it can wait.
- 72deluxe 7y agoI used email in the early ISDN days on a shared network. Perhaps people's expectations of how much data (base64!) they want to shove in an email have changed since then. I did once use 2G to VNC over SSH to a machine for work and that was painful, but usable. Colour depth had to be pretty low for it to work though. We just love ever-increasing data usage, with about the same level of actual content (text).