4 ms·
I think we need to forgo charging entirely on EVs, and start swapping batteries at gas stations like you would an empty propane tank for a full one. I saw a de
by asdff 7y ago
I think we need to forgo charging entirely on EVs, and start swapping batteries at gas stations like you would an empty propane tank for a full one.
I saw a demonstration of an electric moped that worked like this. You pull up to the station, put your empty batteries in the rack for charging, and take a set of full ones.
Fully charged EV faster than filling up a tank of gas.
- Pxtl 7y agoThat's fine for tiny things like mopeds and scooters, but for a full sized vehicle that means half a tonne of batteries.
- asdff 7y agoMaybe we should rethink how we design our electric vehicles. Still, if the batteries are all mounted along the bottom plate, it wouldn't be too hard to engineer a solution that can drop out, roll away, and have a fresh battery array be reinserted into the vehicle. We've been siloing our thinking that an EV should be some quasi hybrid between plugging in your phone to charge, and putting in a gas pump into a car. The best and most practical EV in the future will look nothing like a car today. Maybe in the future we will just bring back street car wiring to our cities and run an antennae above the vehicle like a bumper car.
- matt_morgan 7y agoI have a charger for the car on 240V, in our garage. It charges fully in about 2 hours. Mind you this is a plug-in hybrid, with only ~20 mi range before the gas comes on. But still that's lots better than swapping out lots of heavy batteries. Swapping batteries makes sense for a car you don't own. For a car you own, I don't know. Of course car ownership is probably going away soon enough.
- asdff 7y agoTwo hours sucks compared to twenty seconds. It doesn't have to be you swapping the battery. Could be the pimple faced kid working at the gas station, or a robot.
- matt_morgan 7y agoYes, it takes longer. But it happens while I'm sleeping, and requires no special trip. I do think swapping batteries will be the sensible way to handle this when we're also swapping cars, or when the cars drive us, unless charging times come way down.