5 ms·
This article seems misguided. It's assuming Stadia is "floundering" because it doesn't have a ton of indie titles, assuming those are "critical" for success.
by crazygringo 7y ago
This article seems misguided.
It's assuming Stadia is "floundering" because it doesn't have a ton of indie titles, assuming those are "critical" for success.
But are they? The article is clear that Google is working with "EA, Bethesda, Ubisoft, 2K Games, and Rockstar Games".
Google is obviously consciously choosing a product strategy of starting with major publishers rather than indie ones.
Now I don't personally know if that's the right strategy. But it's clearly the strategy Google is pursuing, so they should be judged on whether that's working.
Judging solely on the presence of indie titles just seems weird.
- iandanforth 7y agoI paid for the Founders Edition, eagerly awaited its release, played a couple games for a few hours and haven't touched it since. I want to play games like I watch Netflix, free with lots of variety. Indie game makers would keep me coming back for no other reason than I want to try new things regularly and I have zero interest in paying $60 for titles I've already played or had no interest in in the first place. Dr. Kate Compton articulates what I want well in this twitter thread: https://twitter.com/GalaxyKate/status/1197227916158996481 https://twitter.com/GalaxyKate/status/1197227916158996481
- setpatchaddress 7y agoTwitter won’t load for me right now, but it sounds like you want Apple Arcade.
- SanchoPanda 7y agoTwitter will load differently for me depending upon referrer; try reloading by selecting url and hitting enter to make it a direct thing.
- iandanforth 7y agoI'd totally try that if it didn't try to force me to upgrade my OS. Looks interesting though!
- rodgerd 7y agoThe big games will likely be anywhere successful - as the article notes, they're the blockbuster films that will be shown everywhere. The smaller games, like Untitled Goose Game or Rebel Galaxy Outlaw, are what can be the differentiator for whether people use your storefront or your competitor.
- mpalmer 7y agoSpeaking for myself as someone who received Stadia for Christmas, I've enjoyed it quite a bit and I've really only played one game so far, Red Dead 2. The online multiplayer is snappy; while graphic quality could be better, it is not something I'm writing angry letters about. Eventually they will need to release more games to keep me coming back, but I agree that the thrust of the article is not especially convincing. Indie developers are not the de facto bellwethers for a platform's success; you have to make that case as a game journalist. Not sure that happened here.
- drusepth 7y ago>It's assuming Stadia is "floundering" because it doesn't have a ton of indie titles, assuming those are "critical" for success. This is ironic because it seems like replies to every new game release on Twitter bemoan Google for having nothing but indie titles on Stadia.
- ehsankia 7y agoAlso, considering adapting a game for Stadia takes non-negligible amount of time: 1. Before they released Stadia, they could only work with a small handful of developers without too much getting leaked. 2. Now that it's public, it takes time for all the devs to port their games. They did announce that there will be 120+ games in 2020, which matches up with my point above. Most of those probably only started porting mid 2019. Furthermore, if compared to consoles, and not decades of PC history, Stadia does have a reasonable number of games at "launch", though not enough exclusives.
- Yhippa 7y agoHonestly, this reminds me of almost every game launch on consoles. They don't start off with 100 games. They start out with some core games that don't show off the system's full capabilities and then over time the library gets big.