7 ms·
I think/suspect/speculate that since Google has search/ads billions raining from the sky, nothing else it does really matters to them. So all side projects are
by BurningFrog 7y ago
I think/suspect/speculate that since Google has search/ads billions raining from the sky, nothing else it does really matters to them.
So all side projects are done kinda like a hobby.
- wpietri 7y agoMakes sense to me. And I think another factor is that with ads, users are the product, not the customer. If customer service is the foundation of a business, it drives a certain attention on the individual experience of every user, and there's a real incentive to be a customer's #1 choice by the customer's own criteria. But Google's relationship with the userbase is statistical, not individual. As along as enough people look at their ads, that's good enough. They were never intending to please everybody, and so don't really have to pay attention to the details. So it's entirely unsurprising to me that they're failing at gaming, which is very much about delivering amazing individual experiences to one's chosen niche. Ditto their failure in social networking. In both cases they built something that sounded good on paper and could be adequate for some people, but never succeeded in being truly great for enough people to capture an audience.
- icebraining 7y agoGoogle built a pretty successful social network, which even grew faster than Facebook for the first half decade. And like with their messaging services, they then decided it was better to just create a new one from scratch rather than trying to work with what already successful.
- dillonmckay 7y agoOrkut?
- icebraining 7y agoYeah.
- wpietri 7y agoOrkut? I'm not sure we can really count that as something Google created. As I recall, it was a single engineer's side project based on work he did previous to Google. Sure, Google did sort of adopt it. But as you say, it got pushed aside.
- michaelbrave 7y agoReader was kind of a social network too, and would have equally been a great foundation to build on instead of shutting it down for google+
- x0x0 7y agoIt's weird though, because GSuite -- esp google docs, google sheets, and google calendar -- are really good and pretty well supported. So they _can_ do it. Now to be fair, we're rapidly approaching $15k/year in spend with them. I'm desperately wishing google would build a company-aimed wiki because confluence is atrocious. And if anyone is going to deliver cloud gaming, my bet is it's google. It plays to their strengths: their ability to orchestrate and deliver scaled computing at the highest possible speeds. Further, it addresses one of the few markets at a large enough scale to make an impact on their revenues.
- jfim 7y agoI believe docs and sheets were from their acquisition of Writely in the mid 2000s, not something that's homegrown. I wouldn't call docs and sheets good by any means; they're passable at most, with tons of missing features.
- x0x0 7y agoNo doubt they're an ok word processor and a mediocre spreadsheet. That's not what they are though. They're really good group collaboration on docs, particularly content, and collaborative lists with owner assignment. We do a huge amount of editing / signoff / planning / workbacks / etc in them.
- saagarjha 7y ago> I wouldn't call docs and sheets good by any means; they're passable at most, with tons of missing features. And yet they entirely replace Microsoft Office for millions of people.
- esprehn 7y agoDocs and Sheets were entirely rewritten in house many years after the acquisition. They don't work at all like the original products.
- autokad 7y agoI'm guessing you're getting down-voted for that last bit. For one, it's missing the point about what everyone said is important about gaming, and hits the point that everyone said google doesn't understand about customers. why do you think 'deliver scaled computing at the highest possible speeds' = good at gaming? its kind of typical google, 'we offered the best X statistic, therefore they must like it.' for "if anyone is going to deliver cloud gaming, my bet is it's google.", No. If I were to bet money, I would say it would be someone who is good at cloud, or good at gaming. Google is good at neither.
- Heyso 7y agoGoogle users are the people wanting theirs ads to be viewed. Not the one viewing the ads.
- staticassertion 7y agoJust what you want from your service provider.
- vl 7y agoActually most of the Google projects exist to defend Ads/Search combo and to napalm potential threats.
- smadge 7y agoMy thoughts are my own but I think Google is very serious about diversifying their sources revenue away from mostly advertising.
- BurningFrog 7y agoSure, but it's a "nice to have" serious. Not the "life or death" serious companies are for their main business.
- Haga 7y agoLike Ms did, when they created tablets. You can't diversify away from The product. It's logic is baked into everything your company does and how it does it. You need a external unit to do that..
- scarface74 7y agoI don’t doubt they are trying, they just haven’t shown they know how to compared to other large tech companies.
- papito 7y agoGoogle is the world's most expensive post-college hiring and training program, subsidized by the core search/ads cash cow. But it's a really bad one. They killed Reader because it would let them abandon some legacy infrastructure. All other businesses don't have that luxury. They deal with annoying challenges head on. Google's unlimited money basically lets them abandon products when maintaining them stops being fun, or when extra work is required to power through the last 10% and make that product viable for take-off.
- Mindwipe 7y agoI think it's more that Google's management/culture currently doesn't work. Everyone I've ever met there subscribes to the ideology you can soft launch things and build over time. "It worked for Gmail" they say. But ultimately Gmail didn't ask people to shell out real money. And it was a long time ago. Consumer culture has changed, and a launching half finished messy products with no real support or direction really alienates people now. That approach also only really applies if you can give a product away for nothing for a long time to build a userbase. Ruth Porat simply isn't going to let that happen, because Google's new fiscal discipline means she kills products if they don't have a clear path to profitability after three years. And that's the real contradiction. There's nothing wrong with Porat's approach, but Google structurally is not set up to deliver products like that at all. And Google's culture did used to be successful, but can't work with what the Stock Market has made it very clear that Porat is to do (it's extremely clear stockholders like the three year requirement). Ultimately you've got to look at the top of the company for the rot, because senior leadership do not seem to be pulling in the same direction, and as a result you end up with now... when was the last time Google launched a successful consumer product? The Nest Home Mini is probably the closest one, and I suspect that still hasn't made any actual profit with how many they give away.