4 ms·
It's interesting to me how a company like Google can still do things so half-assedly. You'd kind of expect with their resources, they'd to flirt with an idea, t
by Waterluvian 7y ago
It's interesting to me how a company like Google can still do things so half-assedly. You'd kind of expect with their resources, they'd to flirt with an idea, then if they commit, to do it fully. Like, wildly cheap, subsidized gaming solution until they own the market and then turn up the price.
The only answer I can come up with is, "this _is_ their version of flirting with an idea." In which case I think the problem is nobody else realises that given the scale and price tag.
- abvdasker 7y agoMaybe this is silly given Google's vast resources, but I do worry about the future of a company that seems to consistently fall short when it comes to marketing and product management. Google probably still has a lot of the best engineering talent in the world, but without coherent product strategy and marketing what good does it do? When was the last time Google made a big bet that achieved the same level of success as their earlier products? Does Google's inability to diversify its revenue stream make it more vulnerable to disruption than say, Amazon, in the long run?
- lmm 7y ago> Does Google's inability to diversify its revenue stream make it more vulnerable to disruption than say, Amazon, in the long run? Yes. If ads went away, Google would collapse. Google's core search experience is not that good any more, though it's still the best in town; you have to wonder what would happen if Amazon or Facebook decided to actually go after search in a serious way.
- dodobirdlord 7y agoThey do. It is deeply irritating to Amazon that people mostly search Amazon's product catalogue via Google, and only actually navigate to an Amazon controlled page when they go specifically to the product page. Amazon has thrown tremendous resources into building a search experience over their own databases and it still sucks compared to the one Google produced by scraping their website.
- Marsymars 7y agoThe Amazon search experience could be trivially improved to be made better than Google search for me by doing two simple things: 1. No ads, sponsored listings, etc. 2. Let me filter out listings that aren't sold/shipped by Amazon.
- lmm 7y agoI'm sure some part of Amazon must be deeply irritated, just as some part of Google must be deeply irritated that so many people buying products after searching on Google go to Amazon rather than through Google Shopping. But both Amazon Search and Google Shopping suck badly enough that I struggle to believe they are high priorities for their respective companies, whether that's based on an objective view of their own business or because (tacitly or explicitly) they've decided to avoid fighting each other directly.
- true_religion 7y agoFor a company of Googles size, a 100 million dollar outlay of resources is flirting with the market. They can get incredibly polished looking marketing pages, and advertising campaigns without actually committing.
- jonas21 7y ago> Like, wildly cheap, subsidized gaming solution until they own the market and then turn up the price They're probably too concerned about antitrust these days to try anything like that.
- wpietri 7y agoUseful to me here is John Cutler's notion of a "feature factory": https://cutle.fish/blog/12-signs-youre-working-in-a-feature-factory https://cutle.fish/blog/12-signs-youre-working-in-a-feature-... Basically, it's where an executive idea flows through an assembly line that involves marketing, design, product, and eventually software developers. There's no real feedback loop with users; everybody just builds the executive vision for a long time until launch. And then goes on building in a top-down, do-whatever-the-boss-says way. A lot of Google's failures to me feel like some high-level executive getting high on their own vision and/or their desire to conquer a particular market. Which might work if they had the experience, the humility, or the discipline to focus on really serving a specific audience.
- sorenjan 7y agoIt's my impression that Google has been declining since Eric Schmidt left the CEO post. That's probably wrong in a lot of ways, they're making a lot of money and have grown a lot since then, but that's the closest I can think of when trying to find a particular point in time when I as a non investor feel they lost someething. I can't think of a single interesting thing Google has done with Sundar Pichai as CEO, but I guess he's doing something right considering his career. And as long as Google's got that sweet ad money there's really no point in trying to change anything.
- phendrenad2 7y agoI suspect that Google does things to get data. Google Fiber, Google+, Google Stadia, etc. Google is so big that it needs an institutional understanding of adjacent businesses (Comcast, Facebook, the games industry). And how better to gain an understanding than by competing in that space for awhile?
- dodobirdlord 7y agoWhat Google needs is to protect its Ads business (Fiber was a shot across the bow of ISPs, letting consumers know that better was possible) and expand into other similarly-sized markets. Who knows what the future may bring, perhaps targeted digital advertising won't be raking in buckets of cash in 5 or 10 years? If the fortunes of digital advertising go belly-up, Google isn't going to be replacing it with a grab bag of chat apps, phone plans and smartphones. What digital markets exist with current or future revenues in the multi-hundreds of billions of dollars? They tried building a social network, and it didn't work. Doubling down would just further commit them to digital advertising as the entire business. What's left? Enterprise software (GSuite), cloud computing (Google Cloud), video games (Stadia). Any one of those could replace a significant shortfall of revenue from digital advertising if Google could get a significant market share. And significant doesn't have to be that large. Cloud computing market revenue is estimated to be over $500B in 2023, 10% market share in cloud computing would bring in almost a third of Google's current revenue. And 2023 video game market revenue is estimated to be above $200B.