5 ms·
I think this is a wake-up call for these grad students of how the real world works. > Instead of firing TAs who are standing up for a decent standard of living
by csomar 7y ago
I think this is a wake-up call for these grad students of how the real world works.
> Instead of firing TAs who are standing up for a decent standard of living for themselves, UC must sit down at the bargaining table and negotiate a cost of living increase.
Sitting at the negotiations table where you hold none of the cards means you are not getting the pay increase you are asking for. Striking is for workers who know they hold some cards and the other party is not listening.
Striking without any card means you are going to get fired; which just happened here.
- csb6 7y agoI also think it is a good introduction to the real world, but for a different reason: it shows that workers are treated as disposable goods that employers can and will throw away whenever they become too much of a hassle or ask for compensation that reflects the value they bring to the organization. Universities are no different to businesses in this respect; the success of colleges depends on the grunt work of grad students and professors not on the tenure track. Universities will openly deny sane living conditions to these people, and fire them for asking for enough to pay their rents. The way workers in this country are treated is god-awful, and I'm saddened by the people in this thread who are cheering the firing of these students.
- csomar 7y ago> The way workers in this country are treated is god-awful, and I'm saddened by the people in this thread who are cheering the firing of these students. I'm not cheering their firing. I'm just explaining why their strike did not work out as they wished. > ask for compensation that reflects the value they bring to the organization That's not how it works in the real world. You get paid by market rate; which means if there is someone else accepting a pay cut, you'll get fired and replaced. > Universities are no different to businesses in this respect Universities are a competitive business, too; and students pay high tuition fees. If the universities are out-competed, they can lose business/students. It's turtles all the way down.
- csb6 7y ago> That's not how it works in the real world. You get paid by market rate; which means if there is someone else accepting a pay cut, you'll get fired and replaced. I agree, that's true. It's almost as if this is an unjust system that devolves into a race to the bottom and inevitable exploitation of workers. And that in the real world, anyone who tries to fight against this system ends up screwed by their employers. I'm glad we could agree on the exploitation inherent to the labor market.
- allovernow 7y agoThe vast majority of people in the "labor market" are making livable wages. This is not the "unjust system" that a minority at the bottom are complaining about. In any case this "exploitation" is temporary for these student teachers and most importantly as others have pointed out, most of these students are foreign workers and personally I think it's a little exploitive for them to demand entitlements while harming the school to get their way - if it really is so bad no one is forcing them to study here.
- anigbrowl 7y ago[Unprintable]
- dantheman 7y agoHow is it exploitation? These people are students who are compensated while learning -- they're not full time staff. They get a degree at the end.
- jdm2212 7y ago> Workers are treated as disposable Workers are treated as replaceable when they are in fact easily replaced. Grad students aren't even really workers, though. They're students where teaching responsibilities are part of their professional training, and as with most similar positions (apprenticeships and internships), they aren't especially lucrative and there's a line around the block to replace anyone who quits.
- csb6 7y ago> Grad students aren't even really workers "As part of its commitment to transparency and public accountability, each year the University of California publicly reports employee pay data. The report covers UC's career faculty and staff employees, as well as part-time, temporary and student employees." [1] I think the commonly accepted definition of worker is someone who is an employee and not a manager. Grad students are pretty clearly employees, according to the UC system. [1] https://ucannualwage.ucop.edu/wage/ https://ucannualwage.ucop.edu/wage/
- dantheman 7y agoThey're not workers in the traditional sense. What are other workers get degrees for their work?
- michaericalribo 7y agoIf it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then for all intents and purposes, it is a duck. As a grad student, I taught 2 undergraduate courses a semester as the professor, the same load as a full faculty member—very much ‘workers in the traditional sense.’ Moreover, grad students are also writing a dissertation and doing research for their advisors and taking a full course load, and apparently in CA, also working a side job to pay their bills.
- jdm2212 7y agoGrad students teaching courses is, as with interns, a hybrid role that is both paid employment and professional training. And, as with interns, the pay is much lower than an experienced industry veteran's salary [1] because part of the compensation comes in the form of experience, connections and resume-building. [1] There are two exceptions to the rule that interns don't get paid much: professional services and engineering. Both fields use internships almost exclusively as a recruiting tool and don't claim to provide any educational value.
- zdragnar 7y agoYou're overlooking a few details: These workers belonged to a union The union did not endorse the strike The strike occured during a period of operation under an agreed-upon contract Re-opening the contract for negotiation would have lead to renegotiating for 90,000 other employees during a school year The workers were withholding student grades, harming others who have taken out a significant bet against their own futures that they would get good grades and eventually jobs to repay that financial aid There are a number of ways this could have played out, and was basically the second-to-worst case scenario. I am sympathetic to those working under an oppressive union and university, but there really wasn't going to be a different outcome given the path they took.
- beetwenty 7y agoA representative for the union that represents more than 19,000 academic workers across the University of California system said she was surprised by the university's decision. "We are shocked by UC's callousness, and by the violence that so many protesters experienced as they peacefully made the case for a cost of living increase," said Kavitha Iyengar, president of UAW Local 2865, in a statement. "Instead of firing TAs who are standing up for a decent standard of living for themselves, UC must sit down at the bargaining table and negotiate a cost of living increase." Last week, the university filed an unfair labor practice charge against the union, claiming the union has failed to stop the wildcat strike by the graduate students as it is required to do by the collective bargaining agreement. The union responded by filing its own unfair labor practice charge, alleging the university has refused to meet with the union to negotiate a cost of living adjustment. Direct from the article. Care to back up your statement?
- james-skemp 7y agoI thought the same thing as they. From the article: "The strike, which is not authorized by the union that represents the graduate student employees, is in violation of the current bargaining agreement, the university said." It's not clear that the union authorized it, despite what they're quoted as saying further down the article. I don't know enough about unions to know whether they could authorize a strike after not explicitly authorizing initially. It reads like the union didn't authorize the strike, but was fine seeing what would happen/causing a reaction.
- andrepd 7y agoThere is a power asymmetry between the worker class and the capitalist class. By that Gilded Age logic, certainly all unqualified workers -- and many qualified ones as is this case -- do not have the right to strike. It's because of that power asymmetry that there are utterly basic protections such as it being illegal to fire strikers, hire scabs, etc. Your "free market" approach makes for a very dystopic world indeed.
- anonsivalley652 7y agoUnfortunately, "the socialism for the rich and Darwinian austerity for the poor"-mindset is the dominant ideology in American culture. Almost no one else here watches Dr. Richard Wolff or Lee Camp, or reads Angela Davis or Howard Zinn. Until striking workers are being shot by Pinkerton snipers like the Ludlow and Lattimer massacre, most Americans will side with the employers, "workaholism is good for the company," personal self-interest only (no solidarity) and "just pull yourself up by your bootstraps or it's your fault" beliefs.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoYet these are the same people complaining about rising tuition costs.
- specialist 7y agoWhat is impact of grad student wages on tuition costs? Say compared to slashing government subsidies for higher ed?
- dantheman 7y agoIt's hard to think of universities as the capitalist class.
- refurb 7y agoCapitalist class? The government owned and run UC system?
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoWith time, the supply of graduate students should fall. Nobody should want to accept such a deal when these folks could go work in industry and make far money than the UC system will ever pay them. Getting 50-some replacement graduates could be a challenge for UC Santa Cruz. Usually enrollment is on an annual cycle.
- aphextron 7y ago>"Getting 50-some replacement graduates could be a challenge for UC Santa Cruz" It won't be. UCSC is a globally renowned research institute. One of the top public schools in the nation. Not to mention being situated in one of the most beautiful places on earth. There are literally thousands of equally talented people waiting to take these spots. As much as I sympathize with any workers' struggle, these people have no idea how privileged they truly were.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoGetting 50-some replacements before the start of the next academic year. Everyone else is already locked into their plans for the current academic year. After that period passes, I agree with you.
- refurb 7y agoI think this is an important point. The grad students want more pay because housing is so damn expensive in Santa Cruz. Why is it expensive? Because the city refuses to build enough. If their pay doesn't go up, I assume more an more applicants will just pass on Santa Cruz and go for a school where housing is more reasonable and their pay covers most of their expenses.
- awinder 7y agoI had a different impression, which is that they had cards and deployed them poorly. They seem to have whittled the holdouts down to a point where the impact wasn’t so great. But I’m kinda curious if UC doesn’t make grade reporting more incremental now.
- asdff 7y agoGrad students do hold a lot of the cards here. They are frequently required to teach and grade classes, and they perform research critical to their advisors career and the future success of the department. Schools stand to loose training grants as well if research output is diminished, and would fail to recruit grad students who are of high caliber and have choices to go to other schools, so the quality of research would further go down. It's not a tenable position for the school to be in long term, and they are hoping they can scare other students back into line if they start axing students. If anything, this has fired up the students, not made them accept the status quo of loosing money for every year they live and work at UCSC.
- nitwit005 7y agoThey lack much of the risk a normal strike carries. It's not like this is their only possible job with their current credentials. Many of them will probably see a pay increase as a result of getting fired.