5 ms·
Is it really baffling that Google’s product marketing/business people have yet another failing initiative? Have they ever shone any ability to profitably dive
by scarface74 7y ago
Is it really baffling that Google’s product marketing/business people have yet another failing initiative? Have they ever shone any ability to profitably diversify outside of advertising?
- armitron 7y agoNo: https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/
- arkitaip 7y agoNo matter what happens with Stadia and its market, Google simply cannot afford to kill the projects in the next few years. It would be a huge blow to their already tarnished reputation wrt keeping services alive. They need to prove to the world that they can long-term commit to major challenges even if they are suffering in the short-term.
- BigBubbleButt 7y agoJudging by Alphabet's stock price and their years of shuttering services at the cost of their reputation, it seems shareholders disagree with you.
- fmajid 7y agoThey're not mutually exclusive. Google's search and advertising cash cow is so profitable, the company grows despite its boneheaded mistakes in so many other areas. If you read the article, every single developer mentioned they have no trust in Google not canning the service, and who can blame them? At this point, it's becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- BigBubbleButt 7y ago> every single developer mentioned they have no trust in Google not canning the service I never said developers have faith in Google. I said shareholders do. My point is Google doesn't really care what developers think.
- GVIrish 7y agoBut that's kinda the problem. If Google doesn't care what developers think, they are very unlikely to succeed with Stadia.
- BigBubbleButt 7y agoI agree. I actually think Alphabet's long-term (10+ years) future is pretty grim.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoIt doesn't untill it does. Their business depends on developers just like Lehman brother's depended on the mortgage market. Pride before fall, etc. You ignore facts on the ground at your peril.
- scarface74 7y agoSo what happens when more people start using ad blockers and advertisers move more toward FB where ads are harder to block and better targeted? Out of the major tech companies - Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, Facebook and Google. Google is one of the least diversified and has been the least able to pivot over the past decade.
- olivierduval 7y agoThat's why Chrome market share is so important for Google, and why they will stop other advertiser to use it, and adblockers too. Chrome is the advertising channel for Google... and the entry point for Google Ads
- scarface74 7y agoAnd when ad blockers get so much better on other browsers people can switch. Especially now that IE is Chromium based. Also in the US and to a lesser extent other developed countries, the wealthier more lucrative users are using iOS. Google knows this. That’s why they pay Apple a reported 8-12 billion a year to be the default search engine for iOS.
- lmm 7y agoImproving their stock price is exactly what they've been spending their reputation on by doing this - if the stock price had also tanked then this strategy would have been an absolute failure on every axis. It's undeniably bought them better numbers in the short term; the argument is that they are killing their long term potential.
- htrp 7y agothere's an interesting thought exercise i read where someone suggests Google stock would go through the roof if they fired their entire workforce and cut all R&D and just coasted on the ad business
- scarface74 7y agoFor all of the lack of success they’ve had with everything else, if they just focused on Ads, GSuite, Youtube, Android, Chrome, and GCP, how much would it affect their profit?
- Marsymars 7y agoIf that's the case, they should consider some kind of official statement that they'll provide support until at least X date.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThen they have to actually provide support until at least X date. Which, if it’s not successful, they don’t want to do.
- deadmutex 7y ago> They need to prove to the world that they can long-term commit to major challenges even if they are suffering in the short-term. Isn't that Waymo? Disclsure: Work at Google, but opinions are my own.
- lonelappde 7y agoWaymo hasn't launched, so it can't flounder and flop.
- pjmlp 7y agoThis one not at all, as proven by their track record on Android, they just don't know how to talk to game developers.
- scarface74 7y agoOr the enterprise. Between the three cloud providers, GCP is by far the worse when it comes to enterprise engagements or support.
- mmahemoff 7y agoYouTube and GSuite (Docs, Sheets) etc are probably the only other business lines that would work well as big standalone tech companies. Google Play is probably making a decent chunk by running ads, skimming 30% of purchases and new subscriptions + 15% of subscription renewals. That said, there have been other successful products and acquisitions which improved their ad busines. GMail, Maps, Android, Chrome all products with giant user numbers, but whose main contribution is probably to improve ads. Still, a system like Stadia relies on convincing developers that it has a viable future, and it's difficult to build momentum when developers feel burned by the shutdown of other platforms, e.g. Google Plus or Chrome Web Store, where they've sold developers on a bright future, mostly abandoned the platform within a year of launch, and eventually shut it down.
- scarface74 7y agoIt’s estimated that Youtube is barely break even between what they pay creators and bandwidth and storage costs.
- throwaway2048 7y agoevery analysis ive ever seen about YouTube bandwidth costing google vast sums of money completely ignores that they are directly peered with almost every ISP on earth and pay absolutely nothing per byte or per mb/s and just assume they pay level 3 or similar tier 1 provider publicly stated rates. Thats the real moat Google has, to replicate it would likely cost hundreds of millions a month in bandwidth, especially from places where they charge insane amounts (like GCP)
- redis_mlc 7y agoYou could argue that Youtube breaks even. But they pay peanuts to creators, $1k - $3k/million views per monetized video. And they own their own CDN, so bandwidth is a cost they can control or share with other properties. And not operating Youtube would mean another advertising company would have a foothold to compete against them.
- 7y ago