3 ms·
> More likely you just haven't tried to define consciousness clearly and non-circularly, and when you do, it just kind of goes away as a concept. Let me try: c
by visarga 7y ago
> More likely you just haven't tried to define consciousness clearly and non-circularly, and when you do, it just kind of goes away as a concept.
Let me try: consciousness is that which makes you get up in the morning and get something to eat. In general, it's what makes you keep being alive in the complex world, reacting to the changes, adapting for survival. As a human survival entails being part of the human society and culture. This is a concrete, non-metaphysical definition.
Why survival? It's the only self-reliant, self affirming reason.
If you think I am too reductive, maybe you haven't considered the wonderful complexities of reinforcement learning and genetic evolution. There is just as much or more to admire in them as in traditional spirituality and religion. But they have the advantage of being practical and not presupposing things that cannot be seen, including Chalmer's panpsychism and/or dualism.
PS: seems like I hit a nerve, but I am not sorry. Consciousness == eating is my way of crashing the high flying palace of consciousness philosophy into the dirt of the concrete world. Philosophers (armchair or not) need to take heed at the current scientific developments.
- dilyevsky 7y agoSo if i program sdc to drive itself to a charging station when it’s low on battery it’s conscious now?
- visarga 7y agoDoes the sdc make little sdc's, based just on nature? The reproductive organs of technology are us, people.
- robbrown451 7y agoDoes it have goals beyond a simple turn by turn? Can it make complex choices depending on a large number of different things it senses? (presumably weighting different criteria) For instance, is it aware that it is "bad" (i.e. something it should try to avoid) to crash into other cars or pedestrians? Is it aware of other cars on the road? Is it aware that it is also a car, but is different from the other cars in that it is in control of itself? I'm not saying it is conscious, btw, I'm more likely to simply say that consciousness is a poorly defined term, unless you are simply using it to describe a "non-sleeping" state where input from the environment is actively being taken in and processed in a meaningful way. And for that, yeah, a self driving car can be conscious.
- robbrown451 7y agoI am ok with your definition, but I am one to say that a self driving car can indeed be conscious.