3 ms·
“This gives us targets that we may eventually be able to act on with drugs to treat aging in humans.” Oy. Why do we do this nonsense? Why can't it just be rese
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
“This gives us targets that we may eventually be able to act on with drugs to treat aging in humans.”
Oy. Why do we do this nonsense? Why can't it just be research that helps us better understand how to eat healthy?
/pet peeve
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoWhy would you do something hard if we could make it easy?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI don't think the motive is to make it easy. I think the motive is to make it highly profitable for someone.
- pyronite 7y agoI feel like both can be true – the motivation here is likely to both solve a real problem (aging and all that's associated with it) and to make some profit as a result. This is ultimately a product like any other. Like a SaaS product making any hard process easy, you wouldn't expect the solution to be wholly free. People would still have the option to take a different route (caloric restriction) to accomplish the same, but it's clear many people struggle with that.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoMaking hard things easy can be lucrative. Markets work because they align incentives like that.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIf your goal is actually improving the health of people, making money on it can be a case of not aligning incentives. It can be a case of actively undermining your stated goal. X solution: Actually makes people healthy, doesn't make you rich. Gets no press because it's not making you rich. Y solution: Kind of, sort of addresses some health issue, but at the price of terrible, horrifying side effects. Also: Makes someone rich. Gets all the promotion while no one hears anything about the cheap solution that doesn't come with horrifying side effects and a huge literal price tag.
- ve55 7y agoBecause eating healthy is not a full solution to aging, and we can do much better. Would you rather we don't have medication for (type II) diabetes and instead just went around telling people to eat better?
- Nasrudith 7y agoTwo reasons. First the drug could provide better results than the most perect diet it is worth researching period. It is under fewer constraints than an organic system. Second, because the theoretical good and the actual results don't align. We could end many STDs by only monogamously coupling for a generation but that isn't going to happen and virginity pledges haven't helped at all. If "the right way" doesn't actually help in practice can it even be called right?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe problem with virginity pledges is that it's a policy of "just don't find any way whatsoever to meet your needs." Generally speaking, dietary advice doesn't boil down to "All food: bad! People who eat are all going to hell! Stop desiring food at all, you evil sinner you!" I don't think research into how to eat well really compares one-for-one to morality policies of "sex is always bad and we will allow for one and only one right way to ever get laid while still making you feel like shit for wanting it at all."