4 ms·
Can anyone explain to me a rational upside for the Chinese state to over-report detected cases and under-report mortality? Bear in mind, the impact on the domes
by ggm 7y ago
Can anyone explain to me a rational upside for the Chinese state to over-report detected cases and under-report mortality? Bear in mind, the impact on the domestic economy of failing to reign in an epidemic is as real as the upside of claiming it's fixed to settle export income. Basically it's not in any states interest, one party or otherwise. China's domestic economy depends on people getting better.
I truly don't get the assumption "it's worse than they say" when the most likely outcome (putting Hanlons razor into play), is that mortality stats are nearly accurate and caseload is under reported due to lack of testing and self isolation. Death is hard to hide. I believe mortality stats. Any non reported mortality goes to under reported cases, so it evens out.
I know it's optimistic thinking but I am drawn to a belief the effective cumulative death rate in China only drops, as better figures emerge unless unlike all other virus it becomes more lethal not less under mutation.
A different comorbidity outcome eg opportunitistic pneumonia or delayed onset COPD or something, that's different. That would demand a massive change in view. Change in the long-term disease consequence will be interesting and important.
(For instance the effect some disease has on vaccine immunity across the board comes to mind: if this happens, bad news: but, that is in the future)
Well adapted virus mutate not to kill their hosts. Badly adapted virus self limit.
This is not about liking or disliking the Chinese state, I am asking on what grounds people walk to 'under reports of death, over reports of caseload'
No other claim alters mortality into worse places.
Non Chinese deaths predominantly lie in old, lower immunity, comorbidity sick people. And, saying "it's too soon, wait for the wave" is forward facing speculation. Cumulative infection and death rates are inherently backward looking. Explain to me how these a posterior figures get worse not better.
TL;dr it's not smoke, this article is mis applied stupid maths.
Keeping people on a ship (think norovirus and cruises) or having a religious cult uncover huge transmission outcome.. that's not a true reflection of societal risk under self isolation in the home.
I am told the CDC insisted on a home made test. NIH as in "not invented here" and not national institute of health.. bad move guys. Under testing in a US health system with patient cost recovery. That is a recipe for less successful disease control. The US is going to turn out to be under reported. Death rates will probably be right because dying in America is statistically well understood. People won't front for expensive medical test or treatment. High rates of COPD and diabetes and therefore higher risk of death than many other economies. Also large numbers of underinsured older people.
- T-A 7y agohttps://foreignpolicy.com/2020/02/24/xi-jinping-coronavirus-china-covid-19-quarantine/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/02/24/xi-jinping-coronavirus-...
- qqqwerty 7y agoI think your logic is sound, but I assume the folks who claim 'you can't trust the numbers coming our of China' are probably assuming that the numbers are being intentionally underreported for political reasons. I have no idea how those numbers are generated, but I suppose it is at least in the realm of possibility that they could be deliberately reporting lower numbers, and it is not like anyone can really check the math with out doing some extensive verification. Regarding the fact that the death rate appears to be lower outside of China, that would appear to provide evidence against China mis-reporting their numbers (after all, why would they intentionally report a higher death rate). But the one plausible counter point that I have seen, is that the hospitalization/ICU rate is pretty high, to the point where a wave of COVID-19 infections in a short time-span could overwhelm local capacity causing a large spike in mortality. This is most likely why China was building Hospital facilities in Wuhan and why they imposed such a draconian quarantine. So the numbers outside of China might not really be comparable because the number of cases (so far) have been well below local hospital capacity. Unfortunately, it looks like we are going to have a third data point soon. Iran has really poor healthcare infrastructure and they are undergoing a wave of infections. If the mortality rate is heavily dependent on ICU treatment, then Iran might be close to the worst case.
- ggm 7y agoI have read that even when widespread infection is inevitable, simply by changing the slope of the curve it reduces impact, spreading disease control for a broadly similar overall infection rate in time has benefits. The response to any cough or fever should be self isolation. Report by phone. Wait for triage.