2 ms·
That article is relatively sensible, and it also mentions why the writer advocates storing some water, or at least getting a filter, even though they suspect wa
by neilv 7y ago
That article is relatively sensible, and it also mentions why the writer advocates storing some water, or at least getting a filter, even though they suspect water service will continue to operate.
Here's one hypothetical scenario that might be intuitive, not from the article... Say, you live in a dense part of the city, and there's suddenly a lot of confirmed cases around you, so your family decides to stay home for a week, to wait&see how this plays out and what government help arrives. All your city utilities work, but much of the city water utility workers can't afford to live in the city, or otherwise have to stay home, and the remaining workers can't keep up with the ordinary day-to-day level of repairs and maintenance. A pipe fractures, brown water comes out your faucet, and now you have to decide whether to venture out to try to find a store open that has bottled water, and possibly bring the virus back to your family, or stay in and hope water will be fixed and known-safe within 3 days. Ordinary bottle water is $1-$2 a gallon, off-the-shelf from the local store, and some insurance and peace of mind against a very bad and not-too-unlikely situation.
- aaomidi 7y agoOr just boil it at home.
- neilv 7y agoIf your water is coming out brown, like in the example, boiling is likely insufficient. (You really don't want to gamble with needing a doctor/ER at that time.) It also assumes you have a means to boil water. A filter might help in addition to boiling and/or drops, and a filter is one option the article suggests as options for water. I think we'd do a disservice to people by discouraging them from having a modest backup plan for water during a possible pandemic quarantine. Remember the rough "3" rule: 3 minutes without air, 3 days without water, 3 weeks without food.
- double0jimb0 7y agoCopied from above: If you can share one cited example of a water boil alert being issued solely because of persons not showing up to work, I’ll believe your hypothetical. A natural disaster or pipe break that forces a water boil alert could happen any time. Again, I am trying to understand if there is any elevated need to have bottled water at home during pandemic fear vs any other time when run-of-the-mill water boil alerts are issued.
- natalyarostova 7y agoThe short answer is giving you a causal, narrative like reason why you would want bottled water at home during a pandemic doesn't exist. The best argument is that a pandemic is an unknown shock to a system. We don't have any clear reason to put forward a causal hypothesis as to why this shock would damage the water part of our system. But we also know reasoning about complex systems is super fucking hard, and our puny human brains often fail at it (we can barely get right why slightly changing an API can cause entire systems to break). We also know humans die without water, very quickly. Ultimately, it's your call to make.
- xyzzyz 7y agoIf the infrastructure decays so much that there's no drinkable running water, chances are you power and gas are also out.
- IggleSniggle 7y agoOr, you know, just fill a jug at the tap today while the water is good.
- neilv 7y agoIf you have sufficient clean, water-safe containers, and know how to treat the water, and have the time to do it, sure.