15 ms·
It's nice, but very dangerous. I think Clearview AI should have been "taken down" by the government based on reasonable laws (which I guess don't exist). I do
by dathinab 7y ago
It's nice, but very dangerous.
I think Clearview AI should have been "taken down" by the government based on reasonable laws (which I guess don't exist).
I don't think Apple/Google/Amazone or any other company should need to find ways to "punish" a bad actor. Nor should they be allowed to do so as this is a abuse of power and a intervention into politics and moral aspects companies should not do. Nor feel the need to do so. (I mean who decides what constitutes as a "bad actor").
But then we live in times where the Goverment fail to protect their people (at least in cyberspace). Sometimes even repeatedly try to endanger their people (e.g. some of the anti crypto laws). And most importantly increasingly fail to represent the values of large parts of the population.
So I guess it's now the new normal that companies openly (ab-)use their power to push (or hinder) certain thinks which should fall into the area of country governance.
Honestly not really anything new, but sad nevertheless.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- karlkatzke 7y agoBut the government is the main customer of Clearview AI, so why would the government remove it’s own access to a tool?
- newscracker 7y ago> I don't think Apple/Google/Amazone or any other company should need to find ways to "punish" a bad actor. Nor should they be allowed to do so as this is a abuse of power and a intervention into politics and moral aspects companies should not do. Nor feel the need to do so. (I mean who decides what constitutes as a "bad actor"). Apple didn’t take any kind of moral decision here. It just enforced its policy for distribution of apps, just like it did for Facebook and Google last year. The decision is not about whether Clearview’s app or service is a threat to society or privacy.
- ogre_codes 7y agoExactly. A fair number of companies try to use enterprise certificates as a way around Apple's App Store restrictions. The big question is why this company didn't just distribute the software through the App Store. Is it a violation of Apple's App Store policies?
- caymanjim 7y ago> Apple didn’t take any kind of moral decision here. They most certainly did. This is both public virtue signaling and internal employee appeasement. They have good lawyers, so they had the lawyers come up with another reason, but it's purely a moral stance.
- wrboyce 7y agoI’d expect someone making claims like that to have receipts for them...
- cthulha 7y agoYou can disagree with Apple's policies, or the principles and reasoning of others. And I'm sure some of those people are these mythical, awful virtue-signalling hypocrites that people seem to hate so much. But what makes this virtue signalling/hypocritical rather than a values-based decision? Maybe you think Clearview is fine to offer the service, but there are people who disagree based on moral, ethical and practical arguments - and this action seems in line with Apple's stated privacy concerns and prior enforcement of their enterprise distribution agreement.
- wilde 7y agoI mean, I wish that were true. But Apple does a lot of selective enforcement and the app store is full of editorial decisions. I agree with the editorial decision here, and disagree with the HKmap.live editorial decision.
- henvic 7y agoThe state was never about protecting people but protecting its masters (politicians, bureucrats). It's a dangerous precedent to force distribution companies (in this case, Apple) to be able to decide to deny service to a vendor. We want Apple to be able just to get rid of a bad actor. Can people inside Apple theoretically abuse this power? Yes. However, it's way worse if Apple is forced to allow bad actors in the platform. I'd say we might talk about better notarization approaches for app (mobile and non-mobile alike). However, getting rid of any notarization is a step backward.
- scarface74 7y agoSo you expect the same government that is eager to invade your privacy and rights to turn around and protect your privacy? I trust government power a lot less than corporate power.
- lonelappde 7y agoSome corporations also invade privacy, like some governments do. And some protect it.
- Barrin92 7y agoLike you I've also instinctively always been opposed to task private companies with civic duties but in particular seeing the direction both the US and China are heading in terms of privacy I'm begrudingly almost feeling better with companies taking on stakeholder roles. I don't really have any illusions that most of the entrepreneurs aren't full of it when they talk about values but nonetheless it's incredibly sad to see how strongly the very largest governments fail in advocating for civil liberties.
- SturgeonsLaw 7y agoThe government's definition of a bad actor is different to yours and mine. You can lie, cheat, steal, spy, torture and kill, so long as you do it on behalf of, and for the benefit of, a government.
- perl4ever 7y agoI don't think there are any governments that have that policy. For instance, there are complaints when someone gets polonium poisoning, in spite of people thinking it's because of a government. There are complaints about the occupation of Iraq, from governments. And so on.
- chongli 7y agoThere are complaints, but polonium poisoning is a tool of a particular government. The perpetrators who carried out the murder did not face justice, they were given shelter by said government, and very likely rewarded for a job well done. Other governments use drones to bomb people in various countries with impunity. If a private citizen does any of this sort of murder of their own accord, they go to jail. The difference between government and private citizens is that the former can exempt itself from the consequences of these heinous acts. That is what is meant by the term “monopoly on violence.” [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence
- perl4ever 7y agoLegal self defense is a thing, at least in my jurisdiction. So I don't think the government has a monopoly on violence. Also, your opinion on what is murder is arbitrary. All your criticism really is is, "I don't like the definition currently used". That doesn't contain any reason why it should be modified or how or describe any principle.
- chongli 7y agoThe fact that governments can circumscribe the killings they do as “not murder” and have regular people believe them is the quintessential expression of the state monopoly on violence. A monopoly on something doesn’t mean exclusive, 100% godlike control of it. It just means the legitimate provisioning of that thing falls under the authority of one entity. Copyright is a government granted monopoly on the right to copy a creative work but that doesn’t make it impossible for others to make copies, it just makes it illegal.
- powowowow 7y agoThe notion that Apple should not be “allowed” to keep some software out of their App Store is nonsense. It saddens me that a person who claims to care about freedom also wants the government to forbid people from making editorial decisions on their private platforms.
- anoncake 7y agoYou might have a point if Apple did not control the only App store for iOS devices.
- JiNCMG 7y ago"only App store for iOS devices." which was created by Apple. Just like Playstation, Nintendo and Xbox.
- anoncake 7y agoConsoles are problematic for the same reason.
- powowowow 7y agoYes and they have a near total monopoly with their [checks notes] 20% global handset marketshare. You can't just go to Samsung, Huawei, Xiaomi, Oppo, Nokia, or anybody else and get one!!
- anoncake 7y agoDon't deny that lock-in effects are a thing. Not that it Apple's practices less grossly immoral.
- gonzo41 7y agoUntil the wider non tech population can comprehend the danger of things like clearview AI, people who do understand the danger now will have to use tools such as secondary boycots to force change. I guess the choice everyone in SC can make into the future is too avoid and essentially blacklist the people who work for, fund or facilitate the success of companies like clearview AI. People are always talking about culture fit here. Moral fit?
- dzhiurgis 7y agoLaws against facial recognition are futile (a bit like trying to ban tracking on web or encryption). At most you can ban outcomes - persecution, discrimination, etc. But when every Guatemalan farmer can setup their own facial recognition startup - the genie is out of bottle.
- pdkl95 7y ago> At most you can ban outcomes You can also change incentives. If aggregating faces into a database makes you liable for the damage that happens when that database is used, the "Guatemalan farmer" (and any business that wants reasonably prices liability insurance) will go out of their way to avoid making that database.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoNo one is gonna go after couple of misdemeanours in a third world country.
- kevingadd 7y agoNobody is going to buy their Clearview or Palantir grade military/police tech from a third-world farmer, either.
- saagarjha 7y ago> a third-world farmer I think this is a fairly uncharitable view of software engineering in these countries. Many countries by surveillance technology from others.
- kevingadd 7y agoThe grand-parent post specifically mentioned a "guatemalan farmer", so my point was that people typically buy surveillance technology from bigger players instead of from small-time hobbyists and sole proprietors. There's nothing wrong with the software engineering in other countries.
- sjg007 7y agoAmazon sells reckognition which competes with clearview
- alex-wallish 7y agoJust playing devil's advocate here: "Nor should they be allowed to do so as this is a abuse of power and a intervention into politics and moral aspects companies should not do." Your justification for apple not removing them is that it brings them into the realm of making moral decisions which companies should not be making. Yet people call for Clearview AI to make the moral decision of not selling facial recognition tech. It's a two way street. Why should apple not be allowed to make this moral judgement, yet Clearview should have to? Shouldn't Clearview just stay out of moral decisions, and as a company just try to maximize profits?
- cageface 7y agoApple owns the marketplace here so a different set of considerations apply to them compared to individual app makers.
- subaru_shoe 7y agoyou sound like a shill for the likes of clearview etc.