3 ms·
- Are they good people? This is harder to be specific/definite about and probably applies more to the interview stage but a common trait amongst YC
by stcredzero 16y ago
- Are they good people? This is harder to be
specific/definite about and probably applies more to
the interview stage but a common trait amongst YC
founders is that they're always described as good
people
How should one go about being good people? I ask not because I have no clue, but because I'm curious about what others have to say. (Other than being less abrasive when someone on the Internet is wrong.)
- pmjordan 16y agoI assume this is difficult to demonstrate in the written application, except maybe in the negative by displaying questionable ethics in your answers.[1] The video probably isn't great for this either as it's more likely to convey charisma than quality of character. Not being a dick on HN probably helps. Other than that I suspect it's mostly if they a good feeling about you as people at the interview. [1] e.g. admitting to outright scamming people in the "non-computer-hack" answer.
- stcredzero 16y agoCharisma is useful. Ethics are also useful in the same way that the rule of law is. Ethics are also beautiful in the way art is. It's arguably easier and more profitable to do business with ethical people. I met one cocky dot-com bubble ex-startup CEO who thought that creating things of value is piffle and it's all about being cool and getting the payout so one can do nothing but lounge on the beach drinking mai tais in the company of prostitutes. (Sadly, this is not a stereotyped exaggeration, it's exactly what happened and what was said right up to the mai tais, and only the remainder is watered down a bit.) I think there are 100's of ways one can reveal one's ethics to intelligent observers, especially in person, especially over an extended period of time. (Disturbingly, commenting on social news can be just as revealing.) Something that occurred to me in the shower: A useful but disturbing exercise is to start listing your heroes. After you're done with that, start being brutally honest with yourself about how you're not like them. (Then pick out the ways in which this could be turned around as achievable positive goals.) Of all things, it was listening to Timothy Sykes on Mixergy a few weeks ago that's the soil from which this thought sprouted, in particular the part where he talks about meeting his fans and being disillusioned by that. His fans were mostly nothing like him. They were all just people who wanted pretend to be like him. I'm going to start thinking about this in relation to my professional life and with respect to music. (I don't think Mr. Sykes would like me, nor I him, nor do I think I'd care for his writing, but I find I respect him as a perceptive human being.)
- pmjordan 16y agoFor what it's worth, I agree with you completely.[1] What I was trying to say is that it's probably difficult to convey these things in an application form, barring any obvious red flags. I assume the YC gang are pretty good at spotting such negative traits in person though. [1] I tend to be principled to a fault, talking potential customers out of projects they don't actually need and turning down any deals that smell bad. Apart from the fact that I couldn't sleep at night if I didn't, I also think it's a rational strategy.
- nhangen 16y agoI think it's a case of you're either the type or you aren't. Perhaps they stand for something, and aren't susceptible to the whims of external influence?
- stcredzero 16y agoThis comes down to ethics once again.
- krn 16y agoFrom my experience, person's behaviour in difficult situations tells, whether he is "good" or "bad". "Bad people" tend to become negative and destructive, "good people" try to stay positive and creative.
- stcredzero 16y ago"Bad people" tend to become negative and destructive I think this is the root of some very important lines of thought. There are well known reasons why people tend towards negative and destructive behaviors. There are well known ways to encourage positive and creative behaviors. I think these both have to do with the feelings of safety and efficacy. It's one thing to apply such thinking when observing governments overseas. It's another thing to start thinking about that in an entirely personal context.
- pg 16y agoI think what Harj means is not so much that you should become good as that if you are a good person, you shouldn't feel like you need to hide it because e.g. you think it would seem unprofessional.
- danielzarick 16y agoyou shouldn't feel like you need to hide it because e.g. you think it would seem unprofessional. I love this, and thank you for stating it. Too rare do people act genuine and authentic in nature.
- stcredzero 16y agoSorry, but I can't figure out how to connect up the referents so that your comment makes sense to me. I have no idea why someone would want to hide "being a good person" for any interpretation of good subscribed to by people who exist outside of fiction. As for becoming good: I think most people are basically good, but some have acquired pathological behaviors. And of course, it's not the business of someone hiring, a startup, or an incubator to do anything about that, except to exclude it. I think a lot of hackers are angry or at least have a chip on their shoulders because their lives and/or their livelihood lacks efficacy.
- staunch 16y agoSomeone might think "I'd be fine with losing a little revenue per user if it means users are happier with our product", but feel pressure to instead tell investors "We're not going to do that because it would mean less revenue per user". Some people think it looks weak/naive/unprofessional to seem "good" in this way. I'm not sure that's what YC is talking about though.
- webwright 16y agoThis is interesting to me. Is being "good" something that helps you succeed? I hope so. I've been a little disappointed with just how ruthless people at the top tend to be (though I've met plenty of exceptions, PG and JL among them). For every Wozniak who made it to the top, there are 10 Steve Jobs'. Would love to here more about this-- there are obviously a lot of definitions for "good". Maybe this would make a good essay! :-)