3 ms·
And this is the government that HN posters routinely want to “legislate big tech”. But why is this the minority opinion at a conservative conference: I can't
by scarface74 7y ago
And this is the government that HN posters routinely want to “legislate big tech”.
But why is this the minority opinion at a conservative conference:
I can't believe I'm doing this, because I'm here to convince you at a conservative conference that government shouldn't regulate speech,"
- krapp 7y ago>But why is this the minority opinion at a conservative conference: Conservative arguments against the government regulating speech have almost always been presented in the context of preventing the government from regulating conservative speech. Many modern conservatives wouldn't take issue with hypothetical laws limiting the portrayal of nonbinary gender and non-heteronormative characters in TV and film, seeing that as leftist propaganda and an attack on traditional family values. Write a law requiring a baker to make a wedding cake for a gay wedding, however, and conservatives will take to the streets in outrage.
- thu2111 7y agoI haven't seen that. Where do you see conservatives arguing to ban liberal opinions? You appear to be straw manning them. Despite that, I do believe there's a pretty clear need to regulate to protect conservative speech. There's a clear problem with liberals taking over companies that were once neutral and systematically attacking conservatives online. They are much more aggressive about speech control than the other way around.
- scarface74 7y agoI thought the conservative school of thought was to let the market solve the problem? It’s amazing that the same conservatives who think the market can take of care of healthcare even though there is plenty of evidence to the contrary, aren’t capable of doing something much easier like creating a forum. If conservatives don’t like the companies out there they are free to create their own social media companies where they can voice their opinions.
- thu2111 7y agoYou're mixing up conservatism with anarchism. Heck, even anarcho-capitalists recognise some limited role of government in contract enforcement. But anarcho-capitalism isn't mainstream. aren’t capable of doing something much easier like creating a forum. Where did you get that idea? There are conservative forums. They are constantly being attacked by liberals who don't recognise their right to exist at all, with these attacks varying in form but generally falling under the heading of "no platforming". Where do you see conservatives doing the reverse? I've never seen it. they are free to create their own social media companies where they can voice their opinions Yes, you can do that, as long as you don't mind any infrastructure that has liberal owners from trying to no-platform you to death, including things like blocking mobile apps, depeering ISPs and trying to get you blocked from credit card networks. You're making it out like conservatives just have to make some popular websites. They have done, and what we see is liberals viciously attacking anyone who associates with them in any way, including even linking to them. That includes nasty personal attacks on anyone who reads them. I've seen this first hand: someone tried to get me in trouble at work for merely linking to an article on a conservative news website. There's also the workforce to contend with. If you look at the recent story about Kickstarter, their workforce has now unionised because management asked them to take down a project that was raising money to encourage violence against conservatives. That project violated their own ToS so it should have been a no-brainer, but the company became a victim of its own employee's hatred. I worked at Google in the early years and there was a strongly libertarian streak to the firm, as was true of many tech firms back then. Trying to manipulate or control the userbase was an unspeakable taboo. Not tampering with the "organic" output of the algorithms was a strongly held value. But the company didn't try to hire people who shared those values: anyone who could pass a coding test would do and the old timers slowly moved on. The culture war had a clear loser in that case and it wasn't the side that respected the userbase or valued free speech. So it's not enough to merely create a popular website and grow, despite infrastructure firms trying to extinguish you. To create a social media firm that doesn't befall the same fate, you're going to have to take a clear pro-free speech stance from day one, and that will result in being very much slandered and attacked by liberals who see you as an evil to be extinguished. It's wildly extreme and it's well past the point of "free to create your own websites". That freedom is very much hanging by a thread at this point. A major role of government is to stop people within its jurisdiction attacking each other and implementing mob rule. That isn't happening in this case.