4 ms·
Hang on a minute. We alread have AI DMs, without being anywhere near AGI. It's just -they are very limited as DMs and they're not even recognised for being DMs,
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
Hang on a minute. We alread have AI DMs, without being anywhere near AGI. It's just -they are very limited as DMs and they're not even recognised for being DMs, we just think of them as whatever impossibly complicated logic that runs inside a C-RPG and is responsible for managing encounters, handing out rewards, and yes, even advancing the story (such as it is in most C-RPGs), largely through pre-scripted events, of course.
Like I say, this kind of software, pretty common in C-RPGs, is very limited when compared to a human GM, in particular because it cannot present the player with genuinely novel situations and cannot respond to the player's actions with genuinely novel reactions. In other words, the kind of "AI" (ad-hoc game logic) that runs on C-RPGs, is extremely primitive and very unsatisfying, hence the reliance of most C-RPGs on action rather than _inter_action with the players.
Since these kinds of ad-hoc "DMs" are so very limited, even a very small improvement in their ability to interact with the player(s) in surprising and imaginative manners would be a _huge_ improvement.
In the same sense, the ability to reliably generate an interesting story _procedurally_ would be a _huge_ improvement on the current situation, where the majority of procedurally generated game content is just environments with enemies, rewards etc. There are very few games that go a little bit beyond that, e.g. Dwarf Fortress that generates an entire world's mythology and so on.
So there's no need to go as far as AGI. We likely don't even have to go as far as machine learning. The kind of improvement that most gamers would really enjoy is probably within our technological capabilities right now- but there's very little in terms of efforts to make it happen. Why, I'm not sure.
- xamuel 7y agoIf you're willing to stretch things that far, a chess playing robot could be considered a DM who administers an extremely hyperspecific campaign which is isomorphic to chess. Or, tic-tac-toe for that matter. A C-RPG captures D&D in the same sense that a WWII-themed video game captures the true World War II. In other words: not at all. A WWII-themed game applies WWII costumes, sound effects, etc. to an underlying game logic. Switching the WWII costumes to D&D costumes and marketing the result as D&D doesn't really make it D&D.