3 ms·
There is a huge amount of push in media to cripple our devices because some users don't want to reason and use them responsibly. Because Apple limits something,
by izacus 7y ago
There is a huge amount of push in media to cripple our devices because some users don't want to reason and use them responsibly. Because Apple limits something, the assumption is that every other platform now must be limited in the same way and prevent their users from running more powerful software themselves. Because some of them might cut themselves approving too many things.
I don't like that viewpoint.
- criley2 7y agoIt's like quarantine. You might think you're smart enough to wear the right gear and behave the right way to keep others safe, but because some people are irresponsible or don't know how to behave, we enforce the rule on everyone, to keep everyone safe. When we realize that many exploits can mean that devices get co-opted by bad actors to serve some rather nefarious purposes, we have to do more than "trust that the user will be smart" in order to suppress dangerous or economically destructive criminal uses of these devices More and more I realize that it's not our strategies that I dislike, it's how incompetent and error-prone users actually are. If we were perfect users, none of this would be required.
- arsome 7y agoWith quarantine you're preventing the spread of disease which is a general harm to others, with this you're preventing the spread of... your own 2FA codes, which only hurts yourself, if that. Sorry, but I don't think this analogy works. I should have every right to harm myself in any way I see fit. My hardware, my accounts, my control. Preventing accessibility "abuse" does nothing to stop malicious apps from attacking other devices but does a lot to harm accessibility and advanced user features.
- izacus 7y agoQuarantine is actually an apt metaphore here. Apple wants you to stay in the quarantine for the rest of your life because when outside you might ignore the red light and get killed on the road crossing. Or die from other millions of dangerous sources. But staying in a single apartment for the whole life is not healthy for most people or society. Modern computing grew because people were able to build and experiment on things way beyond what the original manufacturers of hardware envisioned. Even if that gave some people Windows viruses.
- criley2 7y agoI understand the "old days" idealism of hacking things in the 80s, but there weren't million computer botnets conducting massive criminal attacks on banks and governments in the 80s. It's a different era. It's like saying "quarantine is pointless in my rural village of 29 people, so therefore it's also pointless in my city of nine million"
- golergka 7y ago> some users While that's technically the truth, it doesn't represent the actual state of events. 99%, and probably 99,9% don't use their devices responsibly. And then companies that bare no responsibility for the actual hack still suffer PR damage, because journalists don't report responsibly too.
- adrianmonk 7y agoIt's not necessarily a good thing, but it is a lesson the software industry is going to have to learn. For example, take the story from a little while back about how Gmail add-ons could access your messages. Any programmer looks at that situation, and they think, "Duh... OF COURSE an add-on could access your data, because how else on earth could it possibly work?" But a non-programmer doesn't think this way. They think, "Gmail is a platform and a service that I use, which is run by somebody that I'm supposed to be able to trust to handle all that stuff for me. They ought to reason through all these things before they offer it to me." They very well may not have a good enough understanding about how software works to reason through the implications like we can. It isn't self-evident to them where your data goes and what will happen to it if you do this or that. moreover, Gmail (and tech generally) isn't the center of their universe, and they may not realize these add-ons come from a third party or may assume a certain level of vetting would be done if they do. Whether this expectation is right is one question. In theory people ought to take responsibility for their own choices. But putting that question aside for the moment, when designing a product, we ought to never forget that many users lack either the knowledge or the inclination to think through all this. You're building a product that you're going to hand over to users, and a lot of users, maybe even the majority of them, are going to approach it this way. I don't have a great solution to offer, but blindly assuming that all users are knowledgeable certainly isn't the right path.
- ascar 7y agoI recently had a discussion with someone who complained about the Gmail permission dialogue when adding his Gmail account to the Windows 10 mail program. He was absolutely convinced that he will not agree to giving Windows permission to view and send emails for him and instead requested that Google and Windows enter a contract that only allows him to do that. It was completely impossible to explain to him the technical background (e.g. that him sending an email through the program and the program sending an email by itself is technically the same thing for Gmail) and he wouldn't accept that Google is quite rightly informing him about the implications (Google should change the text to say it only allows him to send emails). As you said he expected Google to give him technically impossible guarantees and handle that the third party software can't do anything without him confirming it.