4 ms·
Love the spirit of this work, but nobody is an authority on what a melody is. How many different tuning systems were used? Why 8 notes? Why not 0..n notes? [0]
by braindongle 7y ago
Love the spirit of this work, but nobody is an authority on what a melody is. How many different tuning systems were used? Why 8 notes? Why not 0..n notes? [0] Is a given melody, realized at 10ms per beat a melody? How about a 17-month pause before the first note? [1] Absurd? Sure. But who decides where the boundaries are? Lest one think that there is only an appeal to extremes here, check out Polansky's beautiful Lonesome Road, and put boundaries around melodies [2].
[0] https://www.amazon.com/Larry-Polansky-Worlds-Longest-Melody/dp/B003P5AJIU https://www.amazon.com/Larry-Polansky-Worlds-Longest-Melody/...
[1] https://universes.art/en/specials/john-cage-organ-project-halberstadt https://universes.art/en/specials/john-cage-organ-project-ha...
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0aIifUv1Tmk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0aIifUv1Tmk
- eweise 7y ago8 notes is what popular music is based on. I don't see why it matter what the tempo is. Pretty sure no one would be in danger of copyright infringement of a 17 month pause.
- braindongle 7y ago> 8 notes is what popular music is based on. OK, forget everything I said but the 8 notes thing. Just, no. "Yesterday"? Great melody. whistle just the first eight notes. "Yesterday, love was such an eas". Hmm. Wonder if there are more examples.
- db48x 7y ago99% of all music is pop music, and the tuning system for all pop music is 12-tone equal temperament. Would a jury even be able to tell the difference between 12TET and just intonation?