2 ms·
> Having a copyright on this particular piece specifically in a performance context may still be an interesting thought experiment Not even a thought experimen
by derefr 7y ago
> Having a copyright on this particular piece specifically in a performance context may still be an interesting thought experiment
Not even a thought experiment: it’s essentially a 4’33”-long ambient acoustic sample. There are plenty of these (though not usually that long) in sample libraries, recording e.g. traffic sounds, or diner conversation, or crickets in a marsh in summer, etc. And those are certainly copyrighted, unable to be used without license.
- jerf 7y agoYeah, it's more a thought experiment you get in copyright class. You are right, legally the matter is fairly settled.
- salawat 7y ago>Not even a thought experiment: it’s essentially a 4’33”-long ambient acoustic sample. I would question any legal professional's authoritative standing to even advise on copyright of a work of music if they miscategorize a recording of ambient sound as a performance of a musical scoring consisting entirely of silence. The copyright doesn't apply to the ambient sound, but to the long quiessence of an artist at their instrument. It demonstrates a complete blindness of the negative space of music, and a positivistic bias that has no place being enshrined in our legal system.