4 ms·
What helped me with a better understanding of time dilation is short paragraph from RobotRollCall: """ If you're moving through space, then you're not moving
by rdtsc 16y ago
What helped me with a better understanding of time dilation is short paragraph from RobotRollCall:
"""
If you're moving through space, then you're not moving through time as fast as you would be if you were sitting still. Your clock will tick slower than the clock of a person who isn't moving.
"""
- ars 16y agoMaybe it helped you, but it's utterly inaccurate and incorrect. There is no such thing as "moving through space". There is only moving relative to another object. And BOTH of your clocks tick slower! Relative to each other.
- oewolf 16y agoIf you're moving with a speed near the speed of light, time-passing for you will be slowed down compared to a person that is standing still. And if you would stay, say for a minute in that speed and go check on the standing person, you will perceive that she is aging very fast.
- ars 16y agoNo, you would see her aging very slow. Since you are standing still, and it's she who is moving near the speed of light. And if she checked you YOU would be the one aging very slow, since she is standing still and you are moving fast. You are still thinking in terms of absolute motion "you're moving". You are not moving, you can only compare your speed with someone else's.
- oewolf 16y agoHmm so if someone moves near the speed of light, time basically stops for everyone?
- ars 16y agoRemember - he isn't moving near the speed of light THEY are. He is standing still. But if he accelerates then things are quite different, and much more complicated.
- burgerbrain 16y agoFrom which reference-frame are you asking?
- oewolf 16y agoI'm just trying to wrap my head around the concepts discussed here. I used to think about it as I explained in my previous comment. But now that ars is making these comments, it seems like I'm grasping something new.
- ars 16y agoI'll do my best to help. This FIRST thing to remember is that you can only measure speed by comparing with something else. There is no such thing as the concept of "I am moving", but rather "relative to them I (or they, it's interchangeable) are/am moving". Now when you compare speeds you can also compare clocks, and the same principle applies - you can only measure time by comparing to someone else.
- dasil003 16y agoIf that's true, how come the mythical astronaut is young when he gets back to earth while everyone else has aged? Why not the other way around?
- burgerbrain 16y agoThe astronaut accelerated, the people on earth did not.
- dasil003 16y agoThey accelerated away from him though. If there's no absolute frame of reference how can you say who accelerated?
- ars 16y agoBecause unlike speed acceleration is not relative. Acceleration can be measured without reference to anything else. If you are in a box and accelerating you can measure it - it feels exactly like gravity. He feels that gravity, they don't.
- burgerbrain 16y agoIn this example, the earth isn't in an accelerating reference frame, only the astronaut is. There isn't a "master reference frame", but that doesn't mean that acceleration is relative. Despite the upvotes on reddit, this really is a topic that can only be done justice by good book or instructor. Any self-respecting library should have a copy of Relativity: The Special and General Theory by Einstein, it's written specifically for the layman. Come to think of it,... I should probably pick it up again myself.
- modeless 16y agoVelocity is relative, but acceleration is not. The earth-dwellers and the astronaut will both agree that the astronaut accelerated and the Earth didn't. Similarly, rotation rate isn't relative. Acceleration and rotation rate can both be measured against absolute states of no acceleration and no rotation (respectively). This is why our phones have accelerometers and gyroscopes which are entirely internal, but determining velocity, position, and direction require the external references provided by GPS and compass.
- stephth 16y ago"[...] it's utterly inaccurate and incorrect. There is no such thing as "moving through space"." I think you're missing the point here. She's not trying to teach people the perfect semantics, she's trying to progressively teach them concepts that are tricky to understand and assimilate, step by step. And in a way they can relate to. By the way, she addresses what you brought up in her first followup (with yet another compelling and easy to understand explanation).
- ars 16y agoThis is not a matter of semantics, if you ever want to understand relativity the FIRST thing you need to do is get rid of the concept of absolute motion. As long as you think in those terms you will never be able to understand it. And addressing something in a followup is no good - fix your initial post to be correct in the first place. Reddit allows you to edit your post.
- stephth 16y agoIf she had started by explaining relativity her post would have been twice the size and she would have lost half the audience. Doesn't it matter to you that people were actually interested in the topic and participative? And why is a follow up no good? She didn't follow up to fix anything. She followed up to follow up. (And mentioned it by, yes, editing her article).
- burgerbrain 16y agoThe problem here is that when explaining things improperly to be "good enough" you have to be very very careful to make it clear what you're doing. In my opinion, she failed to properly do that and crossed the line between "helpfully simplifying" and "incorrect".
- stephth 16y agoI went through your comments and you mentioned that "in a nutshell" the fact that there's no such thing as a full stop in space is why "this explanation is actually doing a disservice". But that's confusing to me because she clearly stated - relatively to motion - "Those things are true, but we're ignoring that kind of stuff right now." Can you point out exactly where she crossed the line in your opinion?
- chc 16y agoI'm pretty sure he explained that he was talking in terms of general relativity and his simplifying assumption of absolute directions and a stationary viewpoint. As far as I can tell, you haven't explained why that's wrong — merely asserted that there's another viewpoint that can describe the same thing.
- ars 16y agoIf you don't understand that there is no such thing as absolute direction or motion then you don't understand relativity at all. And for him/her to explain things in such a way is a MASSIVE disservice to you and makes it very hard to learn it correctly later. And it's not even your clock that ticks slower - it's theirs.
- rdtsc 16y agoWell what if the coordinate system is in reference to one of the objects. That is what I had imagined in my head, I never supposed an absolute frame of reference. The faster the two objects accelerate from each other, the more the time vector (that she mentions in her explanation) rotates for both of them relative to each other so the slower the relative passage of time.
- ars 16y agoYes, you can say that. (But it isn't what you said before.) And be careful saying "accelerate from each other", once you start including acceleration things become much more complicated.
- rimantas 16y ago> Maybe it helped you, but it's utterly inaccurate and > incorrect. Utterly inaccurate and incorrect as the Newton's second law? :)