2 ms·
>> Riccioli’s work and the star size problem tell us that what was going on in the seventeenth century was not the brave and reasonable Copernicans against powe
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> Riccioli’s work and the star size problem tell us that what was going on in the seventeenth century was not the brave and reasonable Copernicans against powerful forces arrayed to cover up the truth, so much as it was the scientific process at work: a vigorous debate, with good arguments and careful observations on both sides, as each worked to figure out what the truth was.
Yes, vigorous scientific debate with arguments on both sides, as for example the argument of the Inquisition that heliocentricism was heresy.
An argument that the Inquisition certainly defended vigorously. Galileo was tried and found guilty of heresy, forced to recant his heretic views and spent the latter period of his life under house arrest.
It seems the way the scientific process works has changed since Galileo's arrest. We don't expect scientists who voice controversial opinions (i.e. ones that go against the accepted consensus) to be arrested, tried and imprisoned, for voicing such opinions.