6 ms·
> copyright lawyers want to argue originality based on an arrangement of notes in a 12 tone scale Interestingly, there are writers who want to argue originalit
by paulddraper 7y ago
> copyright lawyers want to argue originality based on an arrangement of notes in a 12 tone scale
Interestingly, there are writers who want to argue originality based on the arrangement of letters in 26-letter alphabet!
The world is indeed a strange place for the dogmatically logical programmer.
- ajuc 7y agoThe whole concept of IP is absurd, and there are many absurd consequences you can derive from it. But there are degrees of absurdity, it's one thing to do that when there's 26^100000 possible combinations, it's another when there's just 12^100 (and if you only care about melody it's overestimation, most songs will use much smaller subset of that).
- paulddraper 7y ago> just 12^100 At the risk of getting stuck in a loop: "No rhythms, no meter, no tempo, melodies are longer than 12 notes, it's diatonic, single octave, no concept of underlying harmony" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22441366 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22441366
- ajuc 7y agoI was overestimating, I even mentioned it. > and if you only care about melody it's overestimation And they did it that way because courts don't worry about the exact tempo, meter and rhythm when ruling on plagiarism. There was a guy trying to copyright A CHORD :)
- paulddraper 7y ago> exact tempo, meter and rhythm That much is true. > a guy trying to copyright A CHORD IIRC he failed miserably. A better example would be the (until recently) coprighted song "Happy Birthday." [1] [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/happy-birthday-copyright-suit-settled-n477671 https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/happy-birthda...
- shadowgovt 7y agoIt's not like this absurdity was unknown to the framers of copyright. Thomas Jefferson, writing regarding patents, wrote "other nations have thought that these monopolies produce more embarrassment than advantage to society..." And yet, they persist (and in the modern era, proliferate) because it's generally agreed society derives benefit from paying people for their purely-idea creative work. ... but that doesn't mean copyright and patent aren't a perpetual battle against the "natural" arrangement of idea, and absurdities are extremely possible when the law is misinterpreted or mis-structured.
- JadeNB 7y ago> And yet, they persist (and in the modern era, proliferate) because it's generally agreed society derives benefit from paying people for their purely-idea creative work. Who "generally agree"s on this? The existence of laws doesn't indicate the mood of society.
- shadowgovt 7y ago> The existence of laws doesn't indicate the mood of society. But if laws are proliferating and regularizing instead of standing still or being abolished, and one assumes that elected representatives are acting on the will of the people, it probably does. There's lots of controversy over how to improve copyright / patent law, but not very many people in governments in the EU, US, China, Japan, Australia, &c are talking seriously about just burning the whole copyright / patent system to the ground. At least a subset of the countries in the groups listed are generally understood to have representative governments.
- JadeNB 7y ago> one assumes that elected representatives are acting on the will of the people Yeah, that's the assumption I take issue with.
- Retric 7y agoRepresentative governments are well known for supporting powerful groups over the collective benefit of society. Just look at any of those countries tax codes and you will find a multitude of special exceptions. Patents are of limited duration because the tradeoffs of unlimited patents are so horrific. If we accept a billion dollar drug must enter the public domain, clearly copyright should also be limited just as it was proposed in the US constitution. However, because a tiny minority has a huge benefit and society does not really notice the difference you get the modern mess of unending copyright.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sandov 7y agoIt would be interesting to study what % of programmers agree with IP laws vs people in other fields.
- hsitz 7y agoAnd interesting to include in a study like that how much people in each field actually understood about copyright law. My guess is the general level of understanding is pretty low.
- JackFr 7y agoSome people would tell you it's an ill-posed question. Some might say lumping trademark, copyright, patent and trade secret laws (historically and in practice very different things) under one heading called "intellectual property" is an intentional strategy to muddy the waters and cloud any argument.
- hannasanarion 7y agoYou're not gonna get away with copyrighting a 4-letter sequence, but the recent Katy Perry vs Flame lawsuit established that 4 notes is all it takes to have a copyrightable melody.
- paulddraper 7y agoIt's not four, but eleven letters and two spaces was sufficient for Universal to win against Kamar in the "ET phone home" copyright lawsuit
- logfromblammo 7y agoI would note that 4 minutes and 33 seconds of silence is copyrighted by John Cage as " 4'33" ", and a single chord sustained for 20 minutes, followed by 20 minutes of silence, is copyrighted by Yves Klein as "The Monotone-Silence Symphony".
- jerf 7y agoCage's case is more complicated and less a violation than it may sound at first. It's not 4'33" of "mathematically true silence", that is, you don't violate it per se just by having the right number of zeros in your .wav file. It's 4'33" of performed silence, where the performance is actually the incidental noise of the auditorium it is in. Having a copyright on this particular piece specifically in a performance context may still be an interesting thought experiment, but it doesn't break the system as a whole. In the latter case, there's also no real risk of accidentally stomping on that. The claim in this particular case is that they really have generated the entire possible melody space. Legally I think it's likely to fail on multiple levels if it is ever challenged, but part of the point is that some of those failures should also be applied to some real copyright suits that have been won. (It is somewhat ironic that the music industry continues to be so upset about copyright even as they appear to be converging on The One True Pop Song at speed. Maybe if they acted less like some sort of bizarrely over-trained AI and cranked up the exploration constant, they'd stomp on each other less.)
- molmalo 7y agoWell, somebody should then copyright the whole contents of https://libraryofbabel.info/ https://libraryofbabel.info/ :)
- thaumasiotes 7y ago>> If copyright lawyers want to argue originality based on an arrangement of notes in a 12 tone scale, and in a limited number of bars