5 ms·
I was at embedded world this week, and Asrock, Gigabytes, MSI were all showing rack mounted servers with consumer grade Ryzens. Just by looking at revision num
by baybal2 7y ago
I was at embedded world this week, and Asrock, Gigabytes, MSI were all showing rack mounted servers with consumer grade Ryzens.
Just by looking at revision numbers at their boards, it seems clear that they already went through quite a number of iterations, just as usually happens with more proper server mobos.
There must be a demand for them.
- wil421 7y agoWho do you think is wanting them? Small-Medium business or enthusiasts/prosumers? I can’t see enterprise vendors selling them and I doubt the support is great.
- newsclues 7y agoPfsense router or Server/NAS for home or small office
- Filligree 7y agoFor reference, I use a trio of 3700 servers to run Sufficient Velocity -- a fairly large webforum. That's already overkill. It's nice having the spare capacity, but it would be absolutely foolish to lease a full-blown EPYC trio.
- baybal2 7y ago> I can’t see enterprise vendors selling them and I doubt the support is great. Hosting companies don't end with enterprise cloud stuff. The availability of consumer grade hardware chips has always been much better than server ones for anybody, but tier 1 vendors. Just before there was little incentive to chase that market for anything as even the best consumer grade CPUs still were not contenders on core count, ECC, IPMI support, and cache size to compete with Xeons. But now, even very cheap 3rd gen Ryzens can easily beat mid-tier Xeons: more cores, more cache, ECC support, support for Aspeed remote management. And they are way more power efficient, so making a twin or even a quad system in U1 is possible.
- wazoox 7y agoThere is definitely. Particularly for some applications requiring the highest possible frequency (Ryzens are available in higher frequencies than Epycs). Plus Ryzens support ECC so there are fine server CPUs.
- greggyb 7y agoJust a note, as I was recently slightly disappointed when shopping for RAM for a recent Threadripper build: The current max capacity for Threadripper ECC RAM is 128GB. The largest unbuffered ECC DIMM is 16GB. With an Epyc (or a Xeon) you could used registered memory which is available in higher capacities. If you went 3990X, you'd be limited to 1GB per thread or 2GB per core. This isn't a showstopper, but could be a bottleneck depending on how RAM-intensive your workload is. Let me be clear, I'm still quite happy with my recent purchase and build. Threadripper has enabled unprecedented core counts at very low prices.
- maximente 7y agomind posting your ECC Threadripper build?
- greggyb 7y agoI can post a link to a full PCPartPicker list later if you want, or answer specific questions. It's a 3970X with 128GB (link to RAM in sibling thread) of 3000MHz RAM on a GIGABYTE Aorus Master. No processor overclock. Running Noctua's NH-U14S with one of their high-RPM fans. GPU is nothing special - the cheapest card I could find with DisplayPort 1.4+ and HDMI 2.0+ (for potential dual 4k@60Hz - currently dual 2560x1440@60Hz) - it's a Radeon 550. Boots from NVME and has 40TB raw (20TB usable) spinning disk. It's a virtualization host and prototyping workstation. I work primarily in data analytics, and it's not uncommon to have prod servers larger than this. I've got enough headroom to realistically test things at scale.
- simcop2387 7y agoAlong with that, I've not reliably been able to find fast unbuffered ECC ram either. I've seen some 2333MHz stuff but not in 16GB DIMMs and nothing faster actually for sale (I've seen 2400MHz advertised but not actually available). I've got 128GB of 2133MHz and it works fine but it'd be nice to be able to get the extra performance considering how much it matters for the Zen core cpus
- jmorrison 7y agoWould you please post the model numbers? I am overdue to upgrade. Especially interested if the motherboards have multiple LAN ports. Thanks!
- baybal2 7y ago1U2LW and 1U4LW for asrock. This is what I googled out now. Maybe they were showing a model with different board. They have quite a few: https://www.asrockrack.com/general/products.asp#AMD https://www.asrockrack.com/general/products.asp#AMD MSI guy was particularly secretive. MSI appears to actually have a separate sub-brand they don't market around to do server OEM AMD products without loosing Intel partner status.
- jmt_ 7y agoHistorically I've always gone with Intel, but I've been wondering if new AMD CPUs would work well hypervisor hosts. A Ryzen Threadripper 3990x for example has 64 cores, 128 threads, and supports ECC RAM. Intel by comparison doesn't offer anything close to those numbers on a single CPU. So, does anyone have any thoughts as to why using the 3990x or some other similar AMD product wouldn't be a great idea compared to using some Intel solution? Is the, say, dual Xeon approach better in some way I don't know? I can't tell if Intel is actually better these days or if they just benefit from all the contracts they've been able to get with major manufacturers over time.
- name6454 7y agoI can tell you why I just choose a dual Xeon workstation over a thread ripper, despite it being considerably more expensive for lower performance: memory. The threadripper motherboards apparently max out at 256 GB of ram. I put 1 TB on the Xeon machine and could have gone higher if I needed it. It is really too bad, but 64 cores with a max of 256 GB is super unbalanced.
- redbeard0x0a 7y agoStep up to Epyc processors if you need memory, which is the competitor to the Xeon. Threadripper is for enthusiasts, not specifically for servers.
- jmt_ 7y agoThanks, I'm much less familiar with AMD product lines and didn't know about EPYC.
- JohnTHaller 7y agoEPYC supports up to 4TB of RAM. Here's Linus having fun with one back in September. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HuLsrr79-Pw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HuLsrr79-Pw
- brutos 7y agoI was looking for adding at least one Threadripper server to our local HPC system. I only found one ASRock motherboard for TR4, but none yet for sTRX4. I hope we will see 1U rackmounted sTRX4 systems soon. Our new HPC system will mostly consist of Epyc 7742, but having one node with super high single-thread performance would be nice for less well parallelized applications.