5 ms·
and yet, the users tested didn't use the menu to solve the tasks but gave up, so the original point still stands.
by em-bee 7y ago
and yet, the users tested didn't use the menu to solve the tasks but gave up, so the original point still stands.
- bobbylarrybobby 7y agoMaybe they gave up because the question was phrased as “do you know how to do this” and not “I’ll give you $100 if you can do this”
- btschaegg 7y agoI'd say that is intentional, though. The second phrasing won't give you any good results if you're trying to determine the usability of a UI design. Normal users do not hunt for hidden options the moment they encounter a use case for them. In fact, most would probably assume the feature isn't there even if they realized they had a need for a somewhat generic functionality such as moving to ../ If you offer someone money for finding out about something they don't know about, you change their motivation, which is thus completely different from what they encounter in their day to day use of that software. And the latter is the thing you want to improve in the end.
- whytaka 7y agoI've talked with perfectly otherwise intelligent friends who didn't know that on Facebook Messenger, clicking the Phone icon on the top-right of the screen that's present in every single chat view allows you to have a voice call with the person in the chat. It could not get more obvious than this. Some people just need to be taught. They will never discover on their own.
- swiley 7y agoThis is why manuals and help pages along with just one or two good UI abstractions (a la readline with tab completion) will almost always be superior to poking at pictograms. Snapchat style GUIs will probably remain sexy on the other hand.
- rhn_mk1 7y agoI'd rather take away "pictograms need labels" from that.
- rkangel 7y agoReally? I have repeatedly called people on FB, accidentally every time...
- coribuci 7y ago> I've talked with perfectly otherwise intelligent friends who didn't know that on Facebook Messenger, clicking the Phone icon on the top-right of the screen that's present in every single chat view allows you to have a voice call with the person in the chat. My friend, there are a lot of icons in every program. When the smart developer relies on the stupid user (emphasis mine) to guess what he wants without bothering to put a text label or a tooltip describing the role of the button don't expect wonders. And since "material design" it is really difficult to say if an UI element is a button, or a label or just a decoration without clicking on it and opening the Gates of hell. > It could not get more obvious than this. Some people just need to be taught. They will never discover on their own. There was a saying "The only intuitive interface is the nipple". Some people with children say it's an overstatement.
- whytaka 7y ago> My friend, there are a lot of icons in every program. When the smart developer relies on the stupid user (emphasis mine) to guess what he wants without bothering to put a text label or a tooltip describing the role of the button don't expect wonders. And since "material design" it is really difficult to say if an UI element is a button, or a label or just a decoration without clicking on it and opening the Gates of hell. I'm loathe to disagree but at this point, the phone icon is like the icons for designating Men and Women's restrooms. It's practically universal. It's the icon you use to open your phone app on your phone.