4 ms·
I've applied a simple stereotype. Everyone I've ever seen saying "America / society / the world are on a mandatory happy kick" usually segues into a rant about
by jacques_chester 16y ago
I've applied a simple stereotype. Everyone I've ever seen saying "America / society / the world are on a mandatory happy kick" usually segues into a rant about the pharmaceuticals themselves, written in a disparaging tone.
You fit the profile, and it's a profile I find repugnant and dangerous to the mental health of depressed people everywhere.
There is an important difference between unhappiness due to life events and clinical depression. One may trigger the other; but the fact is that depression is a neurochemical disorder that is, in most cases, directly and immediately treatable with cheap, safe, effective pharmaceuticals with a minimum of fuss.
I've had the deep dark nights of despair. The black nights of the soul. I spent years trying to stare down the black dog. It is exhausting and I gained nothing by it. It has borne me no fruit whatsoever.
- Groxx 16y agoIf that's your standard response to such an apparently-vague profile, without them actually stating such things, you're going to be jumping the gun a lot and probably win more enemies than successes. Do you also leap at people who think we're over-medicating?
- jacques_chester 16y agoYou're right that I jumped the gun. I'd apologise, but it would be disingenuous as I still can't shake you out of the profile I put you in at first. It's not fair, and it's not rational, but if there's anything I've learnt from taking zoloft it's that dualism is rubbish. We are illusions of ourselves, running on a largely hacked-together substrate made of meat. I used to put the position that the drugs are over-prescribed, that it's a societal problem etc. But I don't feel that way any more, because thinking like that was another reason that I did not seek treatment. I basically lost my 20s to this disease, I don't want others to suffer as I did. If that means erroneously attacking a few false positives on HN, so be it.
- Groxx 16y agoWould anecdotes help? My sister is bipolar, and medication has helped her immensely. My wife had a pretty bad bout of anxiety / depression that pretty much tanked two years until I convinced her to try some medication - a year of it helped get her over the edge, and she's off and doing much better. Now I'll proceed to shoot somewhere near my foot, maybe hitting it :) I'd rather be understood and disagreed with than misunderstood and have fake happiness. And I would honestly be curious what your take is on this, I obviously haven't experienced everything there is in the world. There's no hard feelings here, I've seen that stance before, and I hate it too. It does indeed prevent people from getting help. My main view with anything that tweaks your brain is that your brain is enormously flexible. Barring issues where you're not making enough / too much of a certain chemical (ie, largely genetic), you quite literally did this to yourself (as bad as that sounds). Your life habits have caused you to get stuck in the loop of depression / anxiety, and it builds on itself, pretty frequently until it controls you unless you are lucky enough to find a way to break out before then. Or someone drags you out. Drugs help get you out of that loop, but if your habits don't change you'll train your brain to go back to where it was in spite of the drugs (and this happens, it's not just dualism / zomg-natural-only. That's part of what causes psychological addictions, and depression is highly addictive). Again, unless there's a more permanent biological problem - then you're using drugs to reach normalcy, which is where your body / brain wants to be anyway. But enforced normalcy while you keep pulling yourself away from it is doomed to failure and high costs. There are plenty of cases of, say, insufficient dopamine production due to genetics. And cases where depression / anxiety have caused chemical imbalances (ie: nearly all, especially severe cases). And the existence of medications to help that is utterly wonderful. But using drugs to ignore a problem isn't a solution. To solve a problem, yes, but that's not how many (possibly most) people use them, in part because of how quickly these medications are leapt at. Can't focus? Try hyperactivity drugs. Can't sleep? Try sleep aids. Can't be happy? Try antidepressants. Therapy, on the other hand, gets nowhere near as much medical support, despite similar success rates and often longer-term solutions. It has plenty of failures as well, everyone's different and there are plenty of bad therapists out there; I'm merely saying that it gets far less support than drugs do.
- jacques_chester 16y agoOK, we're getting dangerously nuanced now, which breaks all the rules of the Internet. I think you're conflating the illusion of consciousness with the brain itself. It is possible to take actions to intervene in my own neurochemistry -- I am a self-observing system. I can avoid situations that upset me, I can spend more time with friends and family, and so on. But my personal experience of depression is that it removes the will to be cured. Yes, you can seek therapy, spend time with friends, take up meditation and these will help. But when you are depressed even the thought of getting help is ... exhausting. A cause for dismay, even. It is a particularly invidious disease. Each of us has different systemic set points for our internal processes -- dynamic equilibria which our systems drift to over time. Most of these are necessary and useful, they keep us alive. But some of us have set points with unpleasant side-effects. Some people have trouble regulating blood sugar, and they use exogenous insulin to do it manually. I have trouble regulating serotonin, and I use sertraline hydrochloride to influence it manually. High doses broke the back of a depressive episode that lasted 5 years. Low doses have kept me functioning since then. Is it perfect? No. I could do without the side-effects, but I expect that as time goes on these drugs will become more specific and effective. Or someone will come up with a gene therapy. Who knows? I do not regard what I experience as fake happiness. It is as real as anybody else's.