3 ms·
When the task was to make a tool, the criticism should not be that there are other tools to do this. So, yeah. If you want a chair, you just go buy a chair.
by taeric 7y ago
When the task was to make a tool, the criticism should not be that there are other tools to do this.
So, yeah. If you want a chair, you just go buy a chair. But if you are curious if a method of furniture making is good, you don't take as evidence someone that orders a chair from a catalog.
- Izkata 7y ago> you don't take as evidence someone that orders a chair from a catalog. That's misrepresenting what's going on. A better parallel is that the person curious about furniture-making still isn't doing everything from scratch. They're gonna go buy wood and tools - they're not creating an axe, hammer, screwdriver, screws, nails, chopping down a tree, and shaping the wood themselves. The furniture-maker is still following the unix philosophy of using and building on prior work.
- taeric 7y agoDepends how you read it. He offered to demonstrate a tool, literate programming. The task he was asked to demonstrate against was counting words. He was not asked to count words, that is different. It was a purposely pedagogical exercise to demonstrate literate programming. Which is itself a pedagogical method to write a program. To that end, reading his program you can learn about how he wrote his program. Reading the shell script can really just learn how the program was written. If you don't know what those commands do, you will not learn it from the script. I don't know Pascal, but most of the other still makes sense to me. Such that I could probably port it. The shell script? Now, again, if the task is just to count the words, you are probably fine with whatever crosses the finish line. If the task is to demonstrate literate programming? How does that help?