3 ms·

Unfortunately Wuhan experience showed that home isolation doesn't work. Caretakers will get infected. People also have needs that will make them or their careta

Unfortunately Wuhan experience showed that home isolation doesn't work. Caretakers will get infected. People also have needs that will make them or their caretakers go outside.

irjustin 7y ago
How did you reach the conclusion that home isolation doesn't work? Seems quite hyperbolic. It works and is part of the whole solution. A clear downside is caretakers/food delivery can get infected, but it is much harder to spread. The data shows that isolation is helping [1], China minus the outside world shows diminishing new cases in China. [1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-cases/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-cases/
- fspeech 7y ago
  That is the point: China does not do home isolation. Wuhan had no choice but to try that in the beginning and it did not work. Things only started to improve when Wuhan were able to collect patients into quarantine sites.
  - irjustin 7y ago
    Ebola is closer to what you're describing. 2-21 days to show symptoms and you're only contagious after symptoms arise. Isolation 100% works. Corona is closer the flu/common-cold in terms of transmission. Quarantining patients is too late. The viral point is the 14-21 day incubation period where patients aren't showing symptoms yet very able to spread the disease, which is the whole reason why it's so scary and affecting the world markets. If Wuhan removed home isolation and everyone was allowed to go back to the old way of life, the virus would spread again. I'm not sure how you can argue against home isolation. I haven't been convinced of what you claim; that it isn't helping.
    - fspeech 7y ago
      Incubation is typically 4 to 7 days. Home isolation depends on compliance. Patients and their families will be hard pressed to comply if their medical and other needs can not be met.

3 ms·

Unfortunately Wuhan experience showed that home isolation doesn't work. Caretakers will get infected. People also have needs that will make them or their careta

by fspeech 7y ago

Unfortunately Wuhan experience showed that home isolation doesn't work. Caretakers will get infected. People also have needs that will make them or their caretakers go outside.

irjustin 7y ago
How did you reach the conclusion that home isolation doesn't work? Seems quite hyperbolic. It works and is part of the whole solution. A clear downside is caretakers/food delivery can get infected, but it is much harder to spread. The data shows that isolation is helping [1], China minus the outside world shows diminishing new cases in China. [1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-cases/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-cases/
- fspeech 7y ago
  That is the point: China does not do home isolation. Wuhan had no choice but to try that in the beginning and it did not work. Things only started to improve when Wuhan were able to collect patients into quarantine sites.
  - irjustin 7y ago
    Ebola is closer to what you're describing. 2-21 days to show symptoms and you're only contagious after symptoms arise. Isolation 100% works. Corona is closer the flu/common-cold in terms of transmission. Quarantining patients is too late. The viral point is the 14-21 day incubation period where patients aren't showing symptoms yet very able to spread the disease, which is the whole reason why it's so scary and affecting the world markets. If Wuhan removed home isolation and everyone was allowed to go back to the old way of life, the virus would spread again. I'm not sure how you can argue against home isolation. I haven't been convinced of what you claim; that it isn't helping.
    - fspeech 7y ago
      Incubation is typically 4 to 7 days. Home isolation depends on compliance. Patients and their families will be hard pressed to comply if their medical and other needs can not be met.