4 ms·
As someone with too many GIS degrees, I feel a level of cathartic release in reading this and thinking that laypersons might be able to improve their map making
by Waterluvian 7y ago
As someone with too many GIS degrees, I feel a level of cathartic release in reading this and thinking that laypersons might be able to improve their map making skills, avoiding some of the more serious cartographic gotchas. It was well-written. The beauty of the ubiquity and greatly-improved UX of modern GIS tools is that everyone can dive in to doing geospatial analysis and building static and dynamic maps. It also means people can accidentally author very misleading visualizations.
Despite this ESRI-backed article on the subject, I think the popular ESRI-driven map dashboard for Coronavirus[1] has a major flaw that violates the crux of this article. Dot density maps _MUST_ be set to scale relative to your map scale, or else you get nightmare scenarios like this one[2]. This is doubly true if the dots are varying in size (which I also think is a fundamentally terrible representation, because people suck at mentally comparing areas). If I were to modify it, I would probably use a choropleth-like representation. Keep the dots equally sized and colour them different shades of red. That way nobody's brain will mislead them into thinking "this larger circle means a larger area is all infected."
[1] https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/bda7594740fd40299423467b48e9ecf6 https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.h...
[2] https://imgur.com/NPhEzk7 https://imgur.com/NPhEzk7
- Mathnerd314 7y agoPersonally I'd use an equal-population cartogram like https://go-cart.io/cartogram https://go-cart.io/cartogram instead of a geographic projection, and a dot map or solid colors based on density. And per the terminology in the article, that ESRI map uses proportionally scaled symbols, not dots.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThanks, yeah I used the wrong term.
- bilekas 7y ago> equal-population cartogram Ah my previous comment was looking for this!
- slavik81 7y agoThat equal population map looks decent enough for the US, but it's pretty poor for Canada. Arbitrary political boundaries vastly distort the size of regions. Northern Alberta, for example, is barely more populated than the Northwest Territories. However, southern Alberta has a bunch of people, so northern Alberta is huge while the North West Territories are squished flat. That pattern holds true for nearly every province, making them all rather misleading.
- bilekas 7y ago> Dot density maps _MUST_ be set to scale relative to your map scale, or else you get nightmare scenarios like this one[2] There are a lot of flaws with the visualizations of the infections. But using choropleth representations would need a population reference no ? I'm genuinely curious, should the range be reflective of the population with the series the infections ? It could then be enhanced with deaths per infections in certain regions, which could be further enchanced with distance to hospitals. I sound like an ass right now but the data is here, we should use it properly to help, and with people like yourself, maybe it would be better than whats being given right now
- Waterluvian 7y agoYou'd need to normalize the data against area but not necessarily a population reference. You're just showing how prevalent an attribute is relative to other areas. Honestly, it's tempting. I should dust off QGIS or Leaflet and try a few examples. But to speak candidly, I'd probably much rather play Lego with my kid tonight.
- bilekas 7y ago> I'd probably much rather play Lego with my kid tonight. That's completely fair enough! Priorities!
- gen220 7y agoAs another commenter pointed out, geographic projections are well-known in the infoviz literature to be problematic, for a number of reasons. Further, two dimensional area (circles) is a particularly terrible dimension to marry to geography, because it’s an additional (and therefore competing) spatial dimension. Color is better, but still has problems (compare Rhode Island to Texas, or populous New Jersey to unpopulated Wyoming/Alaska). And color forces you to bin, which can be misleading. Chloropleths are still harder to read (compare California to Maine, they don’t share an Axis and are irregular shapes, making it hard to compare their areas) than a bar graph or histogram. IMO a logarithmic bar graph is the most reasonable choice, if you want to include population density I’d encode it with opacity and one-dimensional space (a shaded-in bar representing infection, a dark bar representing mortality, and a transparent bar representing total population). If geographic projections are that important to you, you can superimpose those bars on countries. It sucks but it gives you geographic scale. If anyone wants to build this graph, please include an adjacent, different-hued bar encoding the number of tests performed thus far.
- Waterluvian 7y agoYep. Problems everywhere. But maps are by definitions lies (aka abstractions). You decide which lies are more important to minimize depending on your goals.
- gen220 7y agoTotally in agreement. The fundamental lesson of infoviz, in my view, is that visualization is an act of creative distortion: graphs are literally distortion (much like how diaries, photographs, and films are distortions of experience). There’s no such thing as a neutral graph. Making certain things easier to compare might not be the goal. This is why journalistic graph makers must be extra purposeful, and grounded in theory. I don’t believe that laypeople are using geographic distortions poorly with malicious intent, but more likely with ignorance, as the article suggests.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThe Japanese version is even worse with shifting blobs for different zoom levels: https://jagjapan.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/641eba7fef234a47880e1e1dc4de85ce https://jagjapan.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.htm...
- dmos62 7y ago> greatly-improved UX of modern GIS tools I was surprised when you said that. Recently I was doing some georeferecing of historical maps on top of current maps, and I was very disappointed with the choices. That was my first experience with GIS toolkits. I tried ArcGIS, QGIS and a few lesser knowns. I was looking for a good UI/UX, partly because the goal was to teach a non-technical acquintance to do it. There was a shareware toolkit that was exclusively for georeferencing that had a very satisfactory UI, but it had a blocking bug that would cause it to crash.
- Waterluvian 7y agoYeah, that's true. If you walk through a standard GIS toolbox you'll notice that it covers a _lot_ of ground. It's difficult to make all these tools equally generic and straightforward. If you are running ArcGIS or QGIS you're already in "advanced user mode", in my opinion. I'm not sure how common your use case is, but maybe it does need some simpler option (does it exist in Google Earth maybe?). I think a lot of the improvements are in the form of data authoring and presentation. Even just, "hey here's a public participation map of jogging/biking routes, all measured out and hand-optimized for avoiding traffic lights. Check it out and add your own!" has gone from impossible to pretty easy since I began in the field.
- phaedrus 7y agoI used to work for a GIS company. All of these companies' tools are based on whatever software development platform was current when the project was initiated. The mapping tool may grow to be 8, 10, 15, even 20+ years old and new features are continuously added, but never is the underlying software platform upgraded or the tool rewritten. I'm not sure why this is or even if it is peculiar to GIS, or just more visible compared to the many slow-to-upgrade software fields which don't have a UI or which do more server-side. Also I think some of it is also driven by having one or more big customers who themselves refuse to upgrade. The effect was particularly visible as an outside team was developing a greenfield iOS app for our data at the same time as our team maintained their old-new Windows app. The iOS team was able to, as they say, "move fast and break things" and gain accolades for whizbang features. It was interesting to watch them accomplish more with less computing power and a more primitive (IMO) development language (their Objective-C to our C#). Edit: I called it the "old-new" Windows app as there had been an even older app (predating C#) which the C# app replaced. In the circle of life the once-new C# app itself became ossified and stuck with whatever short-sighted design legacy decisions were baked in. There was a lot of technical debt in the codebase. I should say, partially replaced, as they were never (while I was there) able to convince all of the customers to upgrade from the original app built, hence why I say that big customers who can simply refuse to change might be a factor.
- robomartin 7y agoI found this article to be very informative. Most of us don't have an understanding of how nuanced (or not) using maps to display data can be. I wonder if someone with the proper credentials could contact the creator of this website [0] with advice. I seems like a good idea and resource but the map bothered me the very first time I saw it. The color coding is simply wrong and it communicates something that does not align well with reality. [0] https://covid19info.live/ https://covid19info.live/