4 ms·
""" Under these new rules, users can be warned or even suspended for simply “upvoting policy-breaking content within quarantined communities.” """ That's an
by shadowgovt 7y ago
"""
Under these new rules, users can be warned or even suspended for simply “upvoting policy-breaking content within quarantined communities.”
"""
That's an interesting policy. I can see the benefit if one's goal, as owner of a forum, is to constrain the tone of the forum.
I wonder how the tone of Hacker News, for example, is changed by users upvoting comments in clear violation of forum policy.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoI think it would be more effective and less heavy-handed/controversial to take the newgrounds.com approach and give you more voting power if you upvote stuff that doesn't receive @dang-action and less voting power if you upvote stuff that eventually gets blammed/rejected/banned. I always thought it was a clever maneuver on newgrounds' part. Not to say this doesn't already happen on any forums, but my real point is that overtly punishing users with disciplinary action for what they upvote (as Reddit started doing) really seems like the worst of all solutions. Like something that was specifically engineered to maximize user outrage.
- rtkwe 7y agoMaybe, that would require a more complex voting algorithm though which might be constrictive at Reddit's scale. I doubt it would be less controversial though, r/td is already convinced reddit is faking their subscriber count adding a shadowy vote weight to every users account probably wouldn't get a pass.
- preferenca 7y ago>I wonder how the tone of Hacker News, for example, is changed by users upvoting comments in clear violation of forum policy. It seems to me that Hacker News' singular focus doesn't allow for either strong, purposeful ideology nor for people intently metagaming the community to signal boost ideology. Maybe HN has this problem in a lesser capacity for PR submarines/advertising, but it's not nearly as severe as what the people in "the donald" are doing.
- jermaustin1 7y agoAs owner of a large HN dataset (~4M submissions, all the submissions since starting HNNotify.xyz), I've wanted to do some analysis on this. Currently I only collect submissions, but it isn't hard to also look at the users and their age/karma as well.
- runeb 7y agoHow can you own data that is submitted to a site you don't own? Or do users submit to hacker news through your site?
- jermaustin1 7y agoI do not own it in a legal/licensed sense, I own the bytes that are stored in my database. As it it is easily queryable by me, where it wouldn't normally be if only using the API.
- runeb 7y agoAh, thanks for the clarification! English isnt my first language.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoThey just mean they crawl HN and maintain/mirror their own database of its content.
- koolba 7y agoIts more than that. A notifier let’s you know who’s interested in what. Second level analysis of that is trends of interest over time or weighted interest vs influence (measured via user karma).
- mech1234 7y agoThe larger you grow the set of rules the more precisely you can apply selective enforcement.